Subscribe to This Blog | Author Login | Join CEOExpressSelect | Private Label CEOExpress

Theatre Reviews LImited  Your Source for Theatre Reviews in New York City
By David Roberts
Amazon | CNN | Wikipedia | Theatre Reviews Limited | CEOExpress 
David's Blog

  Navigation Calendar
    Days with posts will be linked

  Most Recent Posts

<< 301-350 Posts 351 - 400 of 1053 401-450 >>
Off-Broadway Review: “Lisa and Leonardo” at the New York Musical Festival at the Duke on 42nd Street (Closed on Friday July 28, 2016)

Photo: Timothy John Smith, Lizzie Klemperer, Ravi Roth, and Dennis Holland. Credit: Matt Monath.
Off-Broadway Review: “Lisa and Leonardo” at the New York Musical Festival at the Duke on 42nd Street (Closed on Friday July 28, 2016)
Music by Donya Lane with Lyrics by Ed McNamee
Book by Ed McNamee, Donya Lane, and Michael Unger
Directed by Michelle Tattenbaum
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Never has a musical been so at war with itself than is “Lisa and Leonardo,” the new musical that finished its run at the New York Musical Festival on Thursday July 28, 2016. It is difficult to know how a talented and experienced creative team could create a musical that in almost two and a half hours’ time fails to find a center and a clear meaning for its existence. That is unfortunate for the exceptional cast who – despite their collective craft – seem adrift on a stage cluttered with disconnected concepts, scattered props, and absent a purposive dramatic arc.

“Lisa and Leonardo” focuses on only one – perhaps the most likely – back story for the painting of Leonardo da Vinci’s iconic Mona Lisa: the subject of the painting is Lisa Gherardini del Giocondo who becomes enamored with da Vinci and has a child with him. This could be an interesting subject for a musical but, in order for that to happen, several things would need to happen – none of which is extant in “Lisa and Leonardo” in its present form: interesting and well developed characters; believable and engaging conflicts; an attractive setting; and rich, enduring themes.

The musical’s principals are all exceptional professionals: unfortunately, “Lisa and Leonardo” does not provide them with a suitable project to properly exercise their craft. Lisa (“Bright Star’s” Lizzie Klemperer) and Leonardo (Timothy John Smith) are flat characters without depth and their conflicts poorly developed. The same is true for the remainder of the cast: no character development and no way to find ways to care about them. What is “Lisa and Leonardo” about? The moat around Pisa? The silly antics of a vapid character like Isabella D’Este (a character wasted on Marissa M. Miller)? And why is it not more about the significant relationship between Leonardo and his lover Salai: the show’s creators hand the talented Ravi Roth one of the most uninspiring LGBTQ characters imaginable.

The book is uninspiring. The music is sometimes a melodic reprieve; however, the lyrics are inconsistent in quality. Musical numbers that work are Lisa’s “How the World Looks to Me;” Lisa and David’s (Keaton Tetlow) “If We Decided;” and “Fixed to a Star” sung by the full company. Musical numbers that are numbing at best are “Can You Capture Her for Me;” “From the Master’s Hand;” “How Long Does It Take;” and “All Dressed Up Like Soldiers.” None of these numbers contribute to the progression of the plot and contain oddly uninspired and awkward choreography by Jonathan Cerullo.

It is impossible to know why the “best schemes” of the creative team went “aft a-gley.” Perhaps they launched the show before it was ready for an audience? Perhaps the team itself was at odds about the direction of the musical? Perhaps the blame lies at the feet of the director (Michelle Tattenbaum) who could not possibly have watched the show from a variety of angles in the Duke on 42nd and not seen actors completely visible in the wings waiting for their entrance? Perhaps the scenic designer (Reid Thompson) and the props master (Kate Testa) do not realize how distracting their work is – why, for example, does Francesco’s and Lisa’s home need to be relocated from one end of the stage to another requiring bolts of hanging fabric to be moved across the stage? Whatever the cause, “Lisa and Leonardo” requires a fresh coat of paint before it’s portrait is ready for viewing again.


“Lisa and Leonardo” completed its New York Musical Festival run on Thursday July 28, 2016. For further information on the musical including the cast and creative team, please visit
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, July 29, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Tink!” at the New York Musical Festival at the Pearl Theatre (Through Sunday July 31, 2016)

Elly Noble stars in the title role of “Tink! directed by Rachel Klein, for NYMF at the Pearl Theatre. Credit: Kelly Tunney.
Off-Broadway Review: “Tink!” at the New York Musical Festival at the Pearl Theatre (Through Sunday July 31, 2016)
Book by Anthony Marino
Music and Lyrics by Lena Gabrielle and Lyrics by Greg Kerestan
Directed by Rachel Klein
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

The most significant accomplishment of the new musical “Tink!” is that it will send you flying back to the J.M. Barrie classic, yearning to reclaim the magic and fantasy created by the adventures of Peter Pan, which is sorely missing in this current production, examining the backstory of the infamous fairy Tinkerbell. The book by Anthony Marino strips this lovable character of any charm or enchantment, revealing her as a strong willed, stubborn, self-centered feminist. The attempt to parallel socio-economic issues of modern day is heavy handed and sabotages the otherworldly fairyland. The music by Lena Gabrielle is repetitive, with pop infused tunes possibly targeted for the younger audience this product might attract. Long musical interludes catering to persnickety choreography by director Rachel Klein and Danielle Marie Fusco appear to only showcase their ability, rather than compliment the action and integrate into the plot. The broad direction of Ms. Klein manages to serve the material but creates arrogant caricatures in lieu of impressionable fictional characters.

The cast is top rate, committed to the product and executing their individual tasks with remarkable enthusiasm and energy in the most professional manner. Elly Noble attacks the role of Tink with determination, an enduring smile and a Broadway belt that shakes the rafters. Max Sheldon creates the inscrutable love interest James, with pirate panache and solid vocals. At the end of the first act someone falls from the sky onto the stage and all of a sudden it feels brighter, lighter than air and tingling with an excitement that draws you into the imaginary Neverland. That someone is Kurt Hellerich as Peter Pan. He is the reason to return for the second act. He exhibits a balance of childlike enthusiasm and adult sensibility, physically capturing the lost boy spirit with playful, pliable characteristic movements. His duet with Tink which introduces the second act and the beginning of their relationship is inspiring, igniting their magical adventure. This is the one moment in the production that manifests Barrie’s classic tale and it is short lived.

Although the concept seems interesting material for a musical, perhaps it is better left as a fleeting thought, to entertain your imagination as you immerse yourself in the classic which has served us well for over a century. Peter Pan is a tough act to follow.


“Tink!” performs at Pearl Theatre Company (555 W 42nd St), through Sunday July 31. Tickets are $27.50 and can be purchased by visiting For more information, including the cast and creative team, please visit, Running time is 2 hours with one 10-minute intermission.

Elly Noble stars in the title role of “Tink! directed by Rachel Klein, for NYMF at the Pearl Theatre. Credit: Kelly Tunney.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, July 29, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: The Abbey Theatre’s “Quietly” Shouts Out at the Irish Repertory Theatre (Through Sunday September 11, 2016)

Declan Conlon and Patrick O'Kane in the Abbey Theatre Production of
Off-Broadway Review: The Abbey Theatre’s “Quietly” Shouts Out at the Irish Repertory Theatre (Through Sunday September 11, 2016)
By Owen McCafferty
Directed by Jimmy Fay
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“A bit of shouting – everyone shouts here – it’s the national sport.” – Robert to Jimmy in “Quietly”

Fifty-two-year-old Ian (Declan Conlon) appeals to his teen years’ nemesis Jimmy (Patrick O’Kane) to meet in the neighborhood Belfast pub where they first became aware of one another thirty-six years ago when they were both only sixteen. It is not the same bar really, just the location of that bar from the past, the bar the adolescent Ian tossed a bomb into killing six Roman Catholic men including Jimmy’s father who was quietly watching a football match on the television set he brought from his home.

It seems over the years Ian has been feeling remorse and hopes a meeting with Jimmy might lead to forgiveness, reconciliation, and release from his overwhelming guilt. He envisions the deep-seated tensions between Protestant and Catholic, republicanism and loyalism, criminal and victim melting into mutual understanding and forward movement. This meeting is at the dramatic core of Owen McCafferty’s “Quietly” that is currently playing at the Irish Repertory Theatre in association with the Public Theater. Ian’s confession is witnessed by barman Robert (Robert Zawadzki) who is battling his own demons and his own experience of xenophobia.

After a slow start, Jimmy and Ian tell the story of that night thirty-six years ago from their own points-of-view. Jimmy demands detail from Ian and playwright McCafferty skillfully gives his characters a treasure trove of figurative language and compelling imagery to complete that request. The pictures of that day that have haunted each of them become the stuff of stories of sadness and regret. Of the two stories, Jimmy’s appropriately is more compelling and cathartic. He does not want to make Ian feel guilty, he is not seeking pity from Ian, and he does not want this visit to develop into some kind of remorseful friendship. This somewhat bizarre retelling allows him somehow to reenter a quiet zone, a place where he can have a pint and watch the telly without really watching and cradle himself in the memory of his Dad and his Mum and sort out his own regrets.

Both Patrick O’Kane (Jimmy) and Declan Conlon (Ian) deliver coercive performances. Their use of Mr. McCafferty’s rhetorical devices is impressive and convincing. They build their characters with as much depth as they can and do that with honesty. One wishes the playwright had found a way to give his characters even more depth and roundness so the audience could feel even more deeply for them and connect with them on a more intimate and engaging level. Robert Zawadzki does the best he can to enliven Robert the barman although, again, he needs more than a few texts and calls to the women in his life to deserve an empathic response from the audience.

Alyson Cummins’s set design recreates an authentic Irish pub that might need just a bit more wear-and tear. Sinéad McKenna’s lighting is often subtle leaving the “confessor” in the shadows of the confessional. Jimmy Fay’s direction leaves more space between words than necessary and loses the opportunity to make the first scene as engaging as it ought to be.

The importance of “Quietly” is it in its relevance to the current socio-political climate of deep-seated and systemic racism, xenophobia, gun violence, and terrorism. Most of the planet only sees pictures of the results of these horrors with only a few knowing the stories of the tragedies that continue to pile on top on one another. “Quietly” gives us a brief glimpse, albeit a relatively quiet one, into one of those stories.


The cast of “Quietly” features Declan Conlon, Patrick O’Kane, and Robert Zawadzki with scenic design by Alyson Cummins, costume design by Catherine Fay, lighting design by Sinéad McKenna, sound design by Philip Stewart, AV design by Neil O’Driscoll, and fight direction by Donal O’Farrell. Production photos by James Higgins.

The performance schedule for “Quietly” is Tuesdays at 7:00 p.m.; Wednesdays at 3:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; Thursdays at 7:00 p.m.; Fridays at 8:00 p.m.; Saturdays at 3:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; and Sundays at 3:00 p.m.

Tickets to “Quietly” are priced at $50.00-$70.00 and are on sale now through Irish Rep’s box office by calling 212-727-2737, or online at Running time is 75 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, July 28, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Butler” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Sunday August 28, 2016)

L-R: John G. Williams (as Shepard Mallory) and Ames Adamson (as Benjamin Butler) in Richard Strand’s BUTLER, directed by Joseph Discher, at 59E59 Theaters. Photo by Carol Rosegg.
Off-Broadway Review: “Butler” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Sunday August 28, 2016)
By Richard Strand
Directed by Joseph Discher
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“General Butler, you are fighting a war because some men saw things differently from some other men.” – Shepard Mallory

Based on true events, Richard Strand’s scintillating “Butler,” currently playing at 59E59 Theaters as part of the successful 5A Series, addresses issues of systemic racism extant in the Civil War Era and in the present – racism that threatens the very moral integrity of our nation. The play also addresses how stereotypes divide and threaten relationships. In the first scene, newly appointed Major General Benjamin Butler (Ames Adamson) receives a “demand” from Shepard Mallory a runaway slave (John G. Williams) who has “illegally” entered Fort Monroe in Virginia. The demand, reports Lieutenant Kelly (Benjamin Sterling) is to speak to Butler and to receive asylum from the Major General. Complicating the challenge is the presence of an additional two runaways who accompanied Mallory to the fort.

These three fascinating characters are developed with precision and real depth. Playwright Strand delineates their conflicts carefully and – with the help of history – creates an admirable level of authenticity. These conflicts, and those of Confederate Major Cary (David Sitler) who arrives at the fort to retrieve his commanding officer’s “property,” drive a complicated and intriguing plot that is rich in imagery and figurative language and includes heartfelt drama as well as endearing comedy. This plot recounts how Benjamin Butler deals with Mallory’s request for asylum and discloses skillfully just why Mallory knew he would win his case for asylum despite all of the legal and military odds against him. To say more would be unfair. It is enough to say Shepard Mallory is not the typical runaway slave and Major General Benjamin Butler is not the typical attorney turned general.

Mr. Strand utilizes the rhetorical devices of repetition and parallelism to his advantage in his well-written script. The first several minutes consist of a prolonged dialogue between Butler and Kelly that serves not only to introduce significant exposition but layers of tropes and bits of dialogue that will reappear throughout the script. Often words like ‘protocol’ and ‘provocation’ are tossed back and forth with the speed of a tennis ball at Wimbledon. “Butler” explores the motivations of individuals who make assumptions about others based on appearance and background and individuals who choose to use stereotypes rather than reason to judge others.

Mr. Adamson (Benjamin Butler) and Mr. Williams (Shepard Mallory) portray two remarkable characters neither of whom claims to be very “likable” and both of whom are “arrogant oddities.” Yet their performances could not be more irresistible. Mr. Adamson portrays a giant of a man who knows what is right and knows he has to find the way to do what is right. Mr. Williams portrays a man in mortal danger who knows he has to use every rhetorical device in his arsenal to survive. Benjamin Sterling’s Lieutenant Kelly is the perfect foil for General Butler’s bluster and these two actors make magic together on stage. Mr. Sterling’s timing is impeccable and he imbues his character with a deep authenticity that resonates with the richness of honesty.

This stage magic could not happen without Major Cary’s visit to Fort Monroe. David Sitler’s comedic performance as the intrusive Major is just what the playwright needs to stir up the developing plot and make it even more difficult for General Butler to simply send the runaway slaves on a journey to escape certain killing. Mr. Sitler gives his character a full range of emotion and believability. Shepard Mallory knows all about the Major and warns Butler that since the visitor is “an expert in artillery” he is coming to the fort to accomplish more than retrieving Mallory for his boss. With Major Cary’s hilarious blindfolded entry and exit, the plot thickens.

Jessica L. Parks’s set is exquisite and serves well for the action of the play. Especially welcomed is the outer room from Butler’s office. Ms. Parks has also decorated the set appropriately with charming period touches. Patricia E. Doherty’s costumes are perfect in every way, her uniform for Butler almost exactly matching those worn in his portraits. The contrast between the officers’ crisp uniforms and Mallory’s tattered slave clothing is laden with emotion. Jill Nagle’s lighting design establishes appropriate time and mood changes. Joseph Discher directs with passion and sensitivity and brings out the best in his talented ensemble cast.

“Butler” challenges the audience to reexamine the role of presumption and stereotyping in making judgments about individuals and their worth and to revisit the urgent need to eradicate systemic racism from the fabric of the nation. One expects to see “Butler” beyond its run at 59E59 Theaters.


Produced by special arrangement with Eric Falkenstein, Czekaj Artistic Productions, Ken Wirth, and Catherine Adler/Jamie deRoy, “Butler” is part of the 5A Season at 59E59 Theaters (59 East 59th Street, between Park and Madison Avenues).

The cast features Ames Adamson, John G. Williams, David Sitler, and Ben Sterling. The creative team includes Jessica Parks (scenic design and props); Jill Nagle (lighting design); Patricia Doherty (costume design); Steven Beckel (sound design); and Leah J. Loukas (wig design). The fight choreographer is Brad Lemons. The Production Stage Manager is Rose Riccardi. Production photos by Carol Rosegg.

“Butler” runs for a limited engagement through Sunday, August 28. The performance schedule is Tuesday – Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; Sunday at 3:00 p.m. Single tickets range from $25.00 - $70.00 ($25.00 - $49.00 for 59E59 Members). To purchase tickets, call Ticket Central at (212) 279-4200 or visit Running time is 2 hours with one 10-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, July 27, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Mr. Toole” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Sunday July 31, 2016)

Photo: Todd d'Amour and Laura Butler in "Mr. Toole." Photo by Mike Dote.
Off-Broadway Review: “Mr. Toole” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Sunday July 31, 2016)
By Vivian Neuwirth
Directed by Cat Parker
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“Do I dare/Disturb the universe?/In a minute there is time/For decisions and revisions which a minute will reverse.” T. S. Eliot, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock”

After a successful run at the Huntington Theatre in Boston, “A Confederacy of Dunces” is possibly heading to Broadway. John Kennedy Toole’s picaresque novel was published in 1980 eleven years after his suicide and the novel was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction posthumously in 1981. What an auspicious time to bring to the stage a new play that focuses on the life of John Kennedy Toole and the publishing of his now iconic novel.

Playwright Vivian Neuwirth was Toole’s student at St. Mary's Dominican College in New Orleans and the events of her play “Mr. Toole” are inspired by that experience. In her play Lisette (Laura Butler) a fictional student of Mr. Toole (Todd d’Amour) – at St. Mary’s in New Orleans – confesses her love for her teacher and narrates the story of how the script for his novel eventually got published after his untimely death.

Ms. Neuwirth uses an engaging trope to encapsulate the life of John Kennedy Toole – T. S. Eliot’s “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock.” Mr. Toole teaches Eliot’s poem, the poem that parallels his own struggles with self-worth and self-understanding and his efforts to “dare” to disturb the universe which is his domineering and manipulative mother Thelma Toole (Brenda Currin) who refuses to accept his sexual status and blocks her son’s every effort to separate from her and individuate in the privacy of his own space. Todd d’Amour delivers an authentic and honest performance as Toole and successfully portrays the novelist’s deep longing and hunger for acceptance. His performance is the anchor for this production and provides the soul needed to capture Toole’s depression and deep sadness.

Mr. Toole tries unsuccessfully to get his novel published by Simon and Schuster and much of the play revolves around the series of rejection letters he receives, his attempts to travel to New York City to work with the publisher, and his disappointment at his mother’s insistence that he remain in New Orleans and keep his teaching position to support her and his father John (Richard Vernon) who apparently shows signs of dementia.

The play uses flashbacks to Toole’s childhood as well as scenes at St. Mary’s, Toole’s home, the bars frequented by Toole in New Orleans, and Thelma Toole’s brother Arthur Ducoing’s (Lou Liberatore) home. George Allison’s scenic design features five LED screens that function well to establish these settings.

Director Cat Parker keeps the action moving early on in the performance, but seems to falter near the end when things begin to wobble and it is not clear whether Ms. Currin and John Ingle (who plays the writer Walker Percy who is eventually responsible for publishing Toole’s novel) are having difficulty with their lines or were not given helpful direction in rehearsal. Their important scene together in Percy’s office is not as powerful as it needs to be nor is the play’s final scene with Lisette when the LED screens seem to fail.

That said, “Mr. Toole” is an interesting look into the life of an iconic figure in American Literature and deserves a look at the Midtown International Theatre Festival.


The cast of “Mr. Toole” includes Todd d'Amour, Laura Butler, Brenda Currin, John Ingle, Lou Liberatore, and Richard Vernon.

The creative team includes set design by George Allison, lighting design by Kia Rogers, video design by Eric Siegel, stage management by Earline Stephen, assistant director and stage manager Becky Abromowitz, dialect coach Charley Layton, and co-produced by Vincent Marano. Production photos by Mike Dote.

Performances take place at the WorkShop Theater Company, 312 West 36th Street (between 8th & 9th avenues), 4th Floor, New York, New York 10018. Subways: 1, 2, 3, 7, A, C, E, N, R, Q, W to 34th Street. Tickets are $18.00 and are available at or by calling 866-811-4111 – Running time: 90 minutes.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, July 25, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “A Scythe of Time” at the New York Musical Festival at the June Havoc Theatre (Through Tuesday July 26, 2016)

Photo: Danny Rutigliano, Lesli Margherita and PJ Griffith. Credit: Russ Rowland.
Off-Broadway Review: “A Scythe of Time” at the New York Musical Festival at the June Havoc Theatre (Through Tuesday July 26, 2016)
Book by Alan Harris
Music and Lyrics by Mark Alan Swanson
Directed by David Alpert
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

Creating a musical based on two Edgar Allen Poe short stories, “How to Write a Blackwood Article” and “A Predicament,” is no easy task given the subject matter and the genre. In this day and age, competing with horror films - given the amazing special effects available - trying to frighten, shock or terrify an audience with a stage play (let alone a musical) seems nearly impossible. The talented team of Alan Harris (book) and Mark Alan Swanson (music and lyrics) enlists the challenge and has created “A Scythe of Time,” skirting the issue mentioned above by incorporating some camp and comedy. The result as a whole might be considered unbalanced, lacking in character development and relationships, but the plot is certainly entertaining splattered with comedic overtures, absurd situations and exposing sensational, tabloid journalism. The skeleton of the story addresses themes of artistic integrity, business ethics, narcissism, power, allegiance and devotion. The music has a pop rock feel reminiscent of Frank Wildhorn which keeps the production moving at a good clip, but lacks a good solid anthem or ballad that is memorable and provides a climax. The dramatic arc lacks intensity.

This production is blessed with an incredible cast that discovers all the necessary elements bequeathed them by the deft direction of David Alpert. Lesli Margherita’s depiction of Zenobia is just plain remarkable, demonstrating her instinctive craft as an actor and an incomparable vocal that is striking in power and purity. P.J. Griffith is a perfect counterpart as Blackwood, developing a despicable character with a robust stride and vigorous vocal. Danny Rutigliano develops a stalwart character in Pompey, strong and vulnerable, but coaxing humor out of the most horrific situations. Matt Dengler creates an appealing Malachi with a soothing vocal and intentional determination. The ensemble is finely tuned and serves the product with undeniable commitment. Lighting by Nick Solyom is moody as it casts evil shadows. Costumes by Lindsey McWilliams are spot on and the scenic design by Starlet Jacobs uses the small stage to capture an eerie atmosphere.

At this stage of development it is clear that there is promise in this new musical. Sure it needs some major attention especially with the sketchy book and weak character motivation but nothing that cannot result in a successful product. Listening to the music one can imagine full, lush orchestrations and with the addition of more melodic and lyrical musical numbers there is a hopeful future. Catch the last performance if possible, it is certainly worth a look.


The cast of “A Scythe of Time” includes Lesli Margherita, PJ Griffith, Matt Dengler, Brandon Brune, Blair Alexis Brown, Emily Claire Hughes, Danny Rutigliano, and Alex Syiek. The creative team includes: Starlet Jacobs (Set Design), Lindsay McWilliams (Costume Designer), Nick Solyom (Lighting Designer), David M. Lawson (Sound Designer), Dan Scully (Projection Design), Marisa Levy (Production Stage Manager), Lisa Dozier King (General Manager), Michael Cassara (Casting). “A Scythe of Time” is produced by Nicole Swanson. Production photos by Russ Rowland.

Tickets are $27.50 and can be purchased by visiting Running time is 90 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, July 25, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “ICON” at the New York Musical Festival at the Duke on 42nd Street (Through Tuesday July 26, 2016)

Cast photo by Shira Friedman.
Off-Broadway Review: “ICON” at the New York Musical Festival at the Duke on 42nd Street (Through Tuesday July 26, 2016)
Book by Sebastian Michael
Music and Lyrics by Jonathan Kaldor
Directed by Paul Stancato
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

A tiny foreign nation, a people’s princess, a gay prince, an arranged marriage, a scandal, a revolution, and a fire that destroys lovers’ hopes and dreams certainly makes interesting material for good old-fashioned musical theater. “Perfect,” the opening number of the new musical “Icon,” is derivative of Kander and Ebb in style and tempo and explodes onto the stage to set an exciting tone for the story of Princess Constance - a cross between Princesses Diana and Grace. Unfortunately, about halfway through the first Act, the book by Sebastian Michael seems to lose energy and becomes disjointed and uneven in paralleled storylines and the surprise ending too easily deduced. The music and lyrics by Jonathan Kaldor seem to waver in the direction of an Operetta. The beautiful, lush orchestrations by Igor Kogan and Athan Gousios, match the royal setting and elegant costumes by Liene Dobraja, but it is difficult not to crave the romantic sounds of a string section which is missing.

The overall cast is superb and does what they can to keep the plot moving at a good pace, but at times they are derailed by the hesitant direction of Paul Stancato, who fairs better with some entertaining choreography that livens up the production.

Charlotte Maltby gives a believable performance as the princess, with regal stature and a strong, clear voice exhibiting pure tonal quality. Sam Simahk has that vigorous quality of an operetta character, with a beautiful, full, dramatic and romantic vocal range. Tony Sheldon serves the character of Gualtieri with equal candor and discretion. Donna McKechnie gives us a respectful Miss Vine filled with charm, confidence and vulnerability but waiting nearly two hours to hear her wonderful familiar voice is unjustified with plenty of missed opportunities for musical numbers that could easily convey her emotional performance. At this stage of development there is a glimpse of a fine piece of musical theater but that comes with a great deal of work and many revisions. See for yourself and try to catch one of the final performances as part of the New York Musical Festival.


“ICON” is an Official Selection of the 2016 New York Musical Festival. Executive Producer/General Manager: Simpson & Longthorne Theatricals; Music Director: Jesse Warkentin; Lighting Designer: Isabella Byrd; Costume Designer: Liene Dobraja; Media Designer: Kevan Loney; Casting Director: Michael Cassara, CSA; Production Stage Manager: Lily Perlmutter; Assistant Stage Manager: Hai Alvarez-Millard; Production Assistants: Samantha Stevens; Publicist: Paul Siebold/Off Off PR.
“ICON” plays on the following schedule: Tuesday, July 26, 2016 at 4:00 pm.
Tickets are $27.50 and can be purchased online at or by calling 212-352-3101. For more information, including the full cast, please visit The runtime for “ICON” is two hours, which includes one 15-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, July 25, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Children of Salt” at the New York Musical Festival at the Pearl Theatre (Through Tuesday July 26, 2016)

Photo: Mauricio Martinez and the Cast of "The Children of Salt." Credit: Russ Rowland.
Off-Broadway Review: “Children of Salt” at the New York Musical Festival at the Pearl Theatre (Through Tuesday July 26, 2016)
Music by Jaime Lozano
Book and Lyrics by Lauren Epsenhart based on the Play “Los Ninos de Sal” by Hernan Galindo
Directed by Jose Zayas
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Jaime Lozano’s and Lauren Epsenhart’s new musical from Mexico follows successful entrepreneur Raul’s (Mauricio Martinez) return to his childhood seaside home to visit his ailing grandmother Marina (April Ortiz). The musical begins in the present and, through a series of flashbacks introduces the characters, their conflicts, and how those conflicts brought them and Raul to the present.

After seeing his adolescent love Coral (Barrie Linberg), Raul – now forty years old - regrets leaving his home after the death of his brother Jonas (Javier Ignacio) who died of a drug overdose. His failed relationship with Coral is not Raul’s only regret and his visit dredges up a myriad of memories – many unpleasant – that prompt Raul to want to “rewind” his past deeply regretting he failed to express his love for Coral. He also confronts Sabina (played with a soulful countenance by Florencia Cuenca) the prostitute who befriended him in his teens.

The musical employs the trope – here an extended metaphor – of the biblical story of Lot’s wife (the “pillar of salt” story) to reflect on the regrets of Raul and his friends whose inability to move forward threatened their ability to extricate themselves from their conflicted pasts.

Mauricio Martinez has a stunning stage presence and a powerful voice with a rich tonal quality and range. Joshua Cruz’s character Angel is as despicable as they come and Mr. Cruz successfully gives the character more angel of death than angel of mercy. Both Barrie Linberg (Coral) and Florencia Cuenca (Sabina) have strong voices that deftly interpret their songs. Sabina’s “My Mother Took Me to Mexico City” and Coral’s “I Married A Man” are exemplary. Coral and Raul’s duet “Morena, Carino” is perhaps the best song among the musical’s numbers.

At the musical’s end, Raul finally enters his grandmother’s home and reunites with her through their shared interest in collecting shells on the beach. That meeting stirs in him the desire to move forward in one of the show’s better duets a reprise of “Children of Salt.” The full company – characters among the living and the dead – sing “Tomorrow Starts Today.”

Jaime Lozano’s music is pleasant enough and features a variety of Latin American music styles including rumba, salsa, merengue, tango, and samba. Lauren Epsenhart’s lyrics and book are less pleasing and often diminish the overall strength of the musical. Many of the songs provide important exposition and the give the overall effect of a sung-through musical. Stephanie Klemons’s choreography is minimal and less than original. Arnulfo Maldonado’s beachfront set works well to accommodate the musical’s multiple scenes all lighted well by Zach Blane. The musicians, under Geraldine Anello’s direction are a superb group of performers.

“Children of Salt” works diligently to entertain its audience but falters with a weak book and inconsistently satisfactory lyrics. See the caveat below before deciding whether or not to attend.

Caveat: “Children of Salt” is meant for mature audiences only. There is an abundance of foul language and multiple depictions of drug use. There are also several unacceptable misogynistic and homophobic slurs which the writer could have easily avoided. Additionally, one of the characters is referred to as a “half-breed” in Camaron’s song “Tourist Season.”


“Children of Salt’s” cast includes Nicolas Baumgartner, Mario Cortés, Joshua Cruz, Florencia Cuenca, Javier Ignacio, Barrie Linberg, Mauricio Martínez, and April Ortiz. The creative team includes Arnulfo Maldonado (Sets), Raul Ozuna (Costumes), Zach Blane (Lights), David M. Lawson (Sound), Joshua Quinn (Production Stage Manager) Stark Naked Production (Casting), and Lisa Dozier King (General Management). Production photos by Russ Rowland.

“Children of Salt” performs at Pearl Theatre Company (555 W 42nd St), through Tuesday July 26. Tickets are $27.50 and can be purchased by visiting For more information, please visit, Running time is 1 hour 40 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Sunday, July 24, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “In the Shadow of a Dream” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Saturday July 23, 2016)

Photo: Actor Nick Ryan in "In the Shadow of a Dream."
Off-Broadway Review: “In the Shadow of a Dream” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Saturday July 23, 2016)
By John A. Adams
Directed by Alexander Harrington
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Joey Miller’s (Nick Ryan) dream in college in 1985 is to play professional basketball after graduating. Ideally – like his favorite player Larry Bird – he could play for his favorite team the Boston Celtics. Although he would imitate Bird’s moves on the court, his 5’9” stature prevents him from reaching his dream. But it is not only his height that gets in the way of dream fulfillment. Joey responds to the advances of Rob a gay student at a post-game party by beating him violently. His vicious attack loses Joey his scholarship and his place on the college team and lands him in the hands of a judge that delivers a two-year community service gig at a hospice run by the Chicago Gay and Lesbian Center.

Joey’s on-site supervisor Melinda Curtis (played with a requisite toughness by Laura E. Johnston) assigns him to care for Richard “Buck” Farrell (John Fennessy) a gritty foul-mouthed ex-cop who lives alone and needs help with some light housework and cooking. She recognizes Joey’s deep-seated homophobia and profound anger and reminds him that he can either control his homophobic outbursts or go to prison. Joey’s anxiety about the assignment heightens when Melinda suggests Joey can also have his meals with Buck and stay in Buck’s apartment.

The encounter between Joey and Buck is the gritty stuff of John A. Adams’s play “In the Shadow of a Dream” currently running at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater in Manhattan. As one would expect, the two clash in every possible way each challenging the other’s firmly entrenched stereotypes and prejudices. Mr. Adams’s period piece has layers of disclosure and motivation for the main characters which evolve in the course of the two act play. There are wonderful tropes including the extended basketball metaphor and intriguing parallels between Joey’s and Buck’s seemingly disparate lives.

But it is on their road trip back to Los Angeles to attend a Laker’s game with a side trip to Buck’s family home - to confront his parents and his demons - that rivets the audience in the second half of the play and brings the rising action to the first half to a chilling climax. A spoiler alerts prevents detailed rehearsal of the plot driven by the authentic conflicts of these two well-developed characters. It might be enough to say the action includes: a weapon; the revelation of Buck’s motivation for asking Joey to drive him to Plainfield, New Mexico; the underbelly of Joey’s homophobia and self-loathing; and whether or not Buck saw Joey prior to his assignment as his caregiver.

Nick Ryan and Broadway veteran John Fennessy are the perfect match for the roles of Joey and Buck. Mr. Ryan gives Joey the inner vulnerability and secret longing for authentic connection his angry homophobic persona masks. This young actor uses his craft to portray Joey’s complex range of emotions and layers of self-denial and self-hatred. And Mr. Fennessey brings a deep resilience and complexity to his character Buck Farrell. He skillfully cradles Buck’s pain and rage and parcels them out with a delicious range of emotions and expressions. These generous actors work well together in every way.

Director Alexander Harrington keeps the action moving at a reasonable pace with some quickening needed in the beginning of the second half. Elizabeth Bove plays Buck’s mother Susan with a contemptible core of hatred and Robert Vincent Smith plays Buck’s father who harbors a secret that shatter’s Buck’s expectations. Rounding out the cast is Matthew Porter who handily plays Joey’s coach, a loan officer, and a cab driver.

Hate crimes – often violent ones – continue to be committed against members of the LBGTQ community in major cities and rural enclaves around the United States and throughout the world. “In the Shadow of a Dream” not only highlights those crimes and the entrenched and systemic homophobia extant in our culture; it also focuses attention on the roles played by dysfunctional families, dishonesty, and religious organizations in the maintenance and spread of homophobia and its attendant horrors inflicted on members of the LGBTQ community.


The cast of “In the Shadow of a Dream” includes Elizabeth Bove, John Fennessy, Laura E. Johnston, Matthew Porter, Nick Ryan, and Robert Vincent Smith. The creative team includes Conor Moore (projection and set design) and Samantha McCann (production stage manager).

For more information about “In the Shadow of a Dream,” please visit Tickets remaining for the final performance on Saturday July 23, 2016 at 12:00 p.m. Running time is 75 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, July 22, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Normativity” at the New York Musical Festival at the Pearl Theatre Company (Through Sunday July 24, 2016)

Photo: Cast of "Normativity." Credit Steve Riskind.
Off-Broadway Review: “Normativity” at the New York Musical Festival at the Pearl Theatre Company (Through Sunday July 24, 2016)
Book, Music, and Lyrics by Jaime Jarrett
Directed by Mia Walker
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

“It’s not always the way it is in plays. Not all faggots bump themselves off at the end of the story!” - Michael in “The Boys in the Band” by Mart Crowley (1968)

It must be said that it is refreshing to find a young, talented member of the LGBTQ community using their voice to bring awareness to a valid concern regarding the depiction or treatment of Gay characters found in today’s literature, film and television. “Normativity,” a new musical by Jaime Jarrett (they/them), exposes the “Bury Your Gays” trope and tries to combat the issue, using a clever (although not new) concept for a storyline. The interspersed musical numbers which are more analytical and introspective do not always serve to move the plot forward as much as exposing a character’s feelings. Also there needs to be more of a balance in the controversy, illuminating the positive strides that have already been made, in order to validate the current battle and need for this specific change. To eradicate the entire LGBTQ literary cannon because of negative depiction, would be destroying history and diminishing the past valiant efforts of our Stonewall forefathers and those before them.

The book may be the trying to cover too much territory and could benefit from a keener focus on the subject at hand, the need for more positive gay role models in all literary mediums. The music many times seems to exhibit repetitive style and tempo. The lyrics although revealing sometimes feel too intellectual then emotional. The talented cast puts forth an energy that almost conquers the lack of emotional content but most characters remain two dimensional. This production deftly directed by Mia Walker moves at a steady pace and she is able to accentuate the important categorical issues. Michael’s line quoted above form “Boys in the Band” sums up why this is an important project that needs to continue to development and make changes in order to become a more powerful message to make changes.


The Cast of “Normativity” includes Izzy Castaldi, Christopher Livingston, Soph Menas, Geena Quintos, Aneesh Sheth, Mitchell Winter, and Madeline Wolf.

The creative team includes Kristen Robinson (scenic design), Tristan Raines (costume design), Zach Blane (lighting design), and Shannon Slaton (sound design). Katie Kavett is stage manager. Emily Marshall is musical director; Adin Walker is choreographer; Adam Kaufman is music supervisor; and Rebecca Feldman is casting director. Production photos by Steve Riskind.

For the location and schedule of performances and to purchase tickets for “Normativity,” please visit Running time is 1 hour and 40 minutes.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, July 21, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “The Crusade of Connor Stephens” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Sunday July 24, 2016)

Ben Curtis as Jim Jr. and James Padric as Kris in "The Crusade of Connor Stephens"
Off-Broadway Review: “The Crusade of Connor Stephens” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Sunday July 24, 2016)
Written and Directed by Dewey Moss
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Big Jim’s (James Kiberd) Baptist Mega-Church is expanding. More space is need for its growing congregation. That conservative congregation also seems to need a television studio and a gym with a basketball court for outreach and youth ministries. One of the church’s young recruits is Connor Stephens the teenager the church “took in and helped him and his mama get off the streets.” Connor ends up shooting and killing Tess Williams the six-year-old daughter of Big Jim’s son Jim Jr. (played with a brooding sadness that masks a deep-seated anger by Ben Curtis) and Jim Jr.’s husband Kris (played with a sweetness and deep sadness by James Padric) who is also wounded by Stephens. After the shooting Connor takes his own life.

Dewey Moss’s “The Crusade of Connor Stephens” deals with the events on the day of Tess’s funeral service as the extended family gathers at Jim Jr. and Kris’s home. Jim Jr.’s mother Marianne (played with a submissive explosiveness by Katherine Leask), his Grandma Vivi’n (Kathleen Huber), Kris’s sister Kimmy (played with a charming strength and willfulness by Julie Campbell) and her husband Bobby (played with a charming and powerful devotion by Jacques Mitchell)gather to mourn and to support Jim Jr. and Kris. The surprise guests are Big Jim and Connor’s coach Dean (played with a clever disingenuous loyalty by George Faya). When Big Jim shows up, all hell breaks loose and the grit of Mr. Moss’s script unfolds.

Big Jim is a preacher who commands not only his pulpit but his wife, his mother, and his congregation. The only family member he fails to command is his gay son Jim Jr. Big Jim despises not only what he considers “the sin of his son being gay;” he also despises his son for not succumbing to his authoritarian demands to “return to the fold.” Playwright Moss has created one of the most despicable characters in recent memory. Big Jim’s deep-seated homophobia and his abusive behavior toward his wife and mother is only superseded by his enormous ego. James Kiberd successfully captures Big Jim’s character and brings a level of honesty and rich authenticity to his powerful performance.

It is difficult to say much about the secrets that are revealed when Big Jim visits his son on the day of Tess’s funeral without a spoiler alert. What Big Jim and Dean know about Tess’s death is revealed through a series of flashbacks (one of Big Jim’s sermons), confessions by Grandma, and hard evidence provided by a letter written to Dean just after that Big Jim sermon and prior to the shooting. It is enough to know that these secrets – once revealed – explain not only the events surrounding the shooting of the six-year-old, but disclose decades of “skeletons” in Big Jim’s closet. Kathleen Huber delivers a brilliant performance as the aging matriarch Grandma Vivi’n who has “held her tongue” far too long and chooses honesty and grace as her way forward.

As those skeletons are unearthed, “The Crusade of Connor Stephens” explodes across the stage with a gripping emotional force that brings the day’s considerably bumpy ride to an explosive cathartic resolution.

Dewey Moss directs his engaging play with the care of a playwright and – after creating some distance between himself and his work – he will surely quicken the pace of the action to more exactly match the emotional strength of this important play.

“The Crusade of Connor Stephens” could not be more relevant in the current climate of gun violence in the United States and in the face of the looming anti-LGBTQ platform ready to be unleashed if a particular political party’s victory should occur in November 2016.


The cast of “The Crusade of Connor Stephens” includes Julie Campbell, Ben Curtis, George Faya, Kathleen Huber, James Kiberd, Kathryn Leask, Jacques Mitchell, and James Padric.

For more information about “The Crusade of Connor Stephens,” please visit There are no tickets remaining for this event. Running time is 105 minutes without intermission.
1 Comment - Read Comment | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, July 21, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Either/Or” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Sunday July 24, 2016)

Off-Broadway Review: “Either/Or” at the Midtown International Theatre Festival at WorkShop Theater’s Main Stage Theater (Through Sunday July 24, 2016)
By Dayle Ann Hunt
Directed by Rachel Flynn
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

In Dayle Ann Hunt’s uber-dysfunctional family play “Either/Or,” currently running at the Midtown International Theatre Festival, protagonist Deni Rutland (Courtney Bess) contemplates a way to escape the cycle of abuse and collusion extant in her nuclear family – a family that apparently has not made any effort to address the alcoholism of its head Herbert “Pop” Rutland (Joseph Rose) and the effects of his disease on the entire family system. Mother Edie Rutland (Mimi Bessette) – chief among the enablers – has simply succumbed to her husband’s abuse and allowed him to abuse his family for forty years.

On her fortieth birthday, eldest daughter Deni hopes she can successfully make it from New York City to Hollywood to enroll in a school to train as a professional makeup artist. She tried to extricate herself from the broken family system before without success. Her prior trip to the west coast ended in a meltdown in Phoenix. “Either/Or” takes place at Deni’s fortieth birthday party attended by her younger sister Lorriane (Kathleen Clancy) pregnant with her alcoholic boyfriend’s child and Edie’s favorite grocer Raymond Blackwell (Ken Perlstein) who is a recovered alcoholic. Edie hopes Deni will find Raymond a suitable candidate for marriage. One can easily see where this insipid script is headed. The characters have choices to either remain in the madness or find a way to escape into some self-realization.

As one would imagine, the birthday party is a total disaster: Deni discovers she was/is an unwanted daughter; those present discover the third sister – who has not been home for years – has just married her lesbian partner; and Mom and Pop Rutland’s racism is rampant. Unfortunately, there is nothing new in Ms. Hunt’s script. Her characters are mostly caricatures no one could possibly care about. Only Raymond is a character with an interesting conflict and the playwright does not seem to know what to do with him. The director certainly does not, leaving him standing upstage left muttering, “Maybe I should leave” over and over and over as he ducks dysfunction from all sides.

Rachel Flynn’s direction is all but lacking and the talented cast does its best to fend for themselves to make some sense of Ms. Hunt’s script. Actor Ken Perlstein deserves special mention for drawing on his considerable craft to stay present throughout the play. He knows who Raymond is and his endearing performance of a once-broken man seeking a meaningful connection is exemplary. If only that were enough to recommend a visit to “Either/Or.”


The cast of “Either/Or” includes Courtney Bess, Mimi Bessette, Cathleen Clancy, Ken Perlstein, and Joseph Rose.

For the location and schedule of performances and to purchase tickets for “Either/Or,” please visit Running time is 70 minutes without intermission.
1 Comment - Read Comment | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, July 20, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “The First Church of Mary…” at the New York Musical Festival at the June Havoc Theatre (Through Friday July 22, 2016)

Photo by M. Chris Pennell
Off-Broadway Review: “The First Church of Mary…” at the New York Musical Festival at the June Havoc Theatre (Through Friday July 22, 2016)
Book, Music, and Lyrics by Geoff Davin; Additional Music and Lyrics by Nicole Boggs and KelleyAnn Hocter; Additional Music by David Mescon
Directed by Martha Wilkinson
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“The medium is the message.” – Marshall McLuhan

Evangelist preacher Adamenses Huckster (Geoff Davin) is a huckster indeed. Her “redemptive” message seems simple enough: “You can choose to see things differently.” And that is exactly what the revivalist hopes to accomplish in her fifth annual benefit concert, revival, and pot luck dinner for her First Church of Mary, the Repentant Prostitute’s “ministries.” She wants her congregation to see a dedicated, caring pastor simply raising funds to missionize Hawaiian children; however, what is revealed in Mr. Davin’s high-energy new musical “The First Church of Mary…” currently playing at part of the 2016 New York Musical Festival is a hypocritical charlatan who has consistently preyed on the spiritual aspirations of her congregation. Pastor Huckster is indeed the man behind the curtain no one ought to pay attention to.

Geoff Davin is splendid as Adamenses Huckster (the provenance of that given name will become clear during the musical). It is clear he enjoys playing the female preacher and gives his character an aggressive yet somehow vulnerable persona. He give’s Huckster the level of moral ambiguity needed to carry off the role. Mr. Davin leads the revival with passion and draws the audience/congregation into his scams and schemes with a chilling – and somewhat sultry – performance. Apparently Mr. Davin experienced a pastor like Adamenses in his youth and bases his caricature on that preacher.

Mr. Davin’s strength is in his music and lyrics. The ten soul/gospel songs in the musical are uniformly powerful. Eight of the songs are original with two being traditional spirituals (“Gospel Train” and “Higher Ground”) with additional music and lyrics and arrangements by Mr. Davin. Her revival concert normally features the three voices of the Johnson Sisters; however, the death of one of the sisters leaves Ruwanda (Jennifer Whitcomb-Oliva) and Luwanda (Brooke Leigh Davis) to carry on with ankle-monitored prisoner Shelly Braithwaite (Rosemary Fossee) to fill in. These three vocalists are powerhouses of vocal skill. Their rich multi-tonal voices grab the lyrics of Mr. Davin’s songs and deliver them with unquestionable authority.

Perhaps most impressive is Charlotte’s (Megan Murphy Chambers) “Soldier On” which she delivers after her testimony – the turning point of the musical. Ms. Chambers has a well-trained voice with strong support and has impressive interpretive skills. When Ms. Cambers deliver’s Charlotte’s testimony, the audience sits in awe of the strength of that character.

Guitarist Michael San Miguel leads the SOUL’D OUT NYC band that accompanies the concert. This is a talented group of young musicians who know their instruments well and know how to unite to present a big sound with requisite interpretive skills that make their performance delightful to the ear and to the heart. Mr. San Miguel also delivers an engaging performance as Huckster’s “number one” band member and disinterested “squeeze.”

Interesting characters with believable conflicts manage to support the musical’s plot mostly through song. Mr. Davin’s book is weak and will hopefully develop further in the future. It might even be desirable for him to bring an experienced book writer on board the creative team. Director Martha Wilkinson generally keeps the revival moving at a desirable pace. That pace begins to diminish in the second act, particularly around the revival team’s testimonies. This section of the musical needs tightening. That said, “The First Church of Mary…” is a delightful foray into the underbelly of one errant evangelical ministry too focused on new cars and glitzy vacations for the huckster-at-large.


“The First Church of Mary...” is an Official Selection of the 2016 New York Musical Festival’s Next Link Project. Lighting Designer: Benjamin Weill; Sound Designer: Megan Culley; Production Stage Manager: Katie Veglio; Publicist: Paul Siebold/Off Off PR. Production photos by M. Chris Pennell.

The cast includes Megan Murphy Chambers, Geoff Davin, Brooke Leigh Davis, Rosemary Fosse, and Jennifer Whitcomb-Oliva.

Musical accompaniment is by SOUL’D OUT NYC, including Keys: Olivier Court; Trumpet: Paul Tafoya; Sax: Gabriel Richards; Trombone: Nathaniel Ranson; Bass: Louis de Mieulle; Drums: Antoine Cara; and Guitar: Michael San Miguel.

“The First Church of Mary...” plays for four remaining performances at the June Havoc Theatre, 312 West 36th Street (2nd Floor), on the following schedule: Wednesday, July 20, 2016 at 5:00 pm; Wednesday, July 20, 2016 at 9:00 pm; Friday, July 22, 2016 at 5:00 pm; Friday, July 22, 2016 at 9:00 pm. Tickets are $27.50 and can be purchased online at or by calling 212-352-3101. For more information, please visit The runtime is two hours, which includes one 15-minute intermission.
4 Comments - Read Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “Small Mouth Sounds” at Ars Nova at the Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre (Through September 25, 2016

Cast photo by Ben Arons.
Off-Broadway Review: “Small Mouth Sounds” at Ars Nova at the Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre (Through September 25, 2016)
By Beth Wohl
Directed by Rachel Chavkin
Reviewed by Michele Willens

When a play is about something more than boy meets girl or boy meets boy, (or boy becomes girl) it can be an inspiring, even cathartic experience. This week, for example, I saw a show that is theoretically about suffering, but it is funny and touching and relatable. Oh, did I mention that it is also about not talking?

I still recall when my pal Susan said she wanted me to meet her wonderful new friend. I asked where they’d met and she said, straight faced, “at a silent retreat.” Well, now that I have seen “Small Mouth Sounds,” written by Beth Wohl, and playing at the Signature Pershing Sq. complex, I kind of get how that might be possible. The play follows six characters over a few days as they get instructions, follow a manual, but are otherwise left to fend for themselves. In silence.

This is an interesting and enjoyable production in an appropriately intimate venue. (It previously enjoyed a successful run at Ars Nova, the ‘new work incubator’ from which it emerged) The audience sits on two sides of a stage and a long, bare wood floor, so it feels as if we are out in those rural lakeside woods with the ‘hush-hush-ers.’ The performers begin and end on stage, but otherwise roam up and down before us. They are all seemingly in some kind of pain, (lost child, bad marriages, illness and so on) though because they don’t speak, much of this we are left to surmise. The actors are all so good that it is relatively easy to do so. The rather perfect cast includes Max Baker, Babak Tafti, Brad Heberlee, Marcia DeBonis, Quincy Tyler Bernstine, and Zoe Winters.

With one key exception--a funny and sad monologue by Heberlee at what is supposedly a Q and A night--the only spoken words come via the invisible leader of the retreat. Voiced by Jojo Gonzalez, he is unintentionally hilarious. “Perhaps the key to enlightenment,” he suggests in between hacks, “is cough medicine.” At another moment, his word of advice to the fragile group is “CHANGE!” We watch these six individuals sort of get to know one another: flirting and then some in the case of one man and woman; a lesbian couple bickering and mending; the most touching character sharing a secret with another through a photograph.

There is a surprising amount of humor, sparked by the smallest actions and expressions, and plenty of tears. (Theirs not ours) It’s amazing when you are spending almost two hours in virtual silence, how sound effects like a sneeze, the opening of a bag of goldfish, or leaves blowing in the rain can sound like a bomb exploding. The noise is from the action on stage, by the way, not from the closely listening audience.

The squeamish should be warned that “Small Mouth Sounds” has frontal nudity, though it is harmless, in character, and almost charming. The play, nicely directed by Rachel Chavkin, is a bit too long and seems to spend the last fifteen minutes in search of an ending. The bottom line turns out to be not much more than “you are not alone.” Still, the pivotal issue is feeling disconnected in these strange and fast times. And who doesn’t?

Words can be very powerful, of course. So, it turns out, can finding other ways to say something.


For complete production information for “Small Mouth Sounds,” including ticket prices and to purchase tickets, please visit
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, July 18, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “No End of Blame: Scenes of Overcoming” at PTP/NYC 2016 at Atlantic Stage 2 (Through Sunday August 7, 2016)

Photo: Alexander Burnett, Christo Grabowski, Valerie Leonard, and Christopher Marshall. Credit: Stan Barouh.
Off-Broadway Review: “No End of Blame: Scenes of Overcoming” at PTP/NYC 2016 at Atlantic Stage 2 (Through Sunday August 7, 2016)
By Howard Barker
Directed by Richard Romagnoli
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“Between my finger and my thumb/The squat pen rests; snug as a gun.” – Seamus Heaney, “Digging”
“Give us a pencil. . .Somebody. . .Give us a pencil.” – Bela in “No End of Blame”

The Potomac Theatre Project is celebrating its thirtieth repertory season in 2016 with ten consecutive seasons in New York City. The Company’s annual visit is always highly anticipated and its exit back to Maryland and Washington, D.C. bittersweet. PTP/NYC brings the highest level of quality in performance and production values and brings its unique brand of engaging theatre to the Atlantic Stage 2 annually. The offerings are not always easy on the audience and the company’s commitment to “engaging dialogue from the stage” is sometimes – but of necessity – deeply daunting.

This is certainly the case with Howard Barker’s 1981 “No End of Blame: Scenes of Overcoming” currently running in repertory with C. P. Taylor’s “Good” through Sunday August 7. Playwright Howard Barker is the consummate wordsmith, a writer whose insistence on being heard and seen can – and should – feel a bit intrusive at times. “No End of Blame” - from the opening scene in 1918 on a battlefield near the Carpathians until the final scene in 1973 in an institution – Hungarian cartoonist Bela Veracek (played with a brooding intensity by Alex Draper) brandishes his pencil and creates political cartoons that not only challenge the status quo but also unequivocally criticize the political-economic systems of the governments he exists within.

In the play’s thirteen scenes (divided into two acts), playwright Barker rehearses events in the life of protagonist Bela that serve to not only provide exposition but also support the main character’s conflict and move the plot forward in engaging and challenging ways – raising rich and enduring questions throughout. What is art – the Franciso Goya hanging in a corporate board room or the Renald Luzier political cartoon in Charlie Hebdo? Which is mightier the brush or the pencil – the oils or the graphite? What does art look like? Could it look like the life of the studio model and not just her/his anatomy? Is there a time the artist should lay down his or her pencil and succumb to the sounds of silence?

The owners of the newspapers Bela works for, including the “Mirror,” often find “a quality of depression” in his work – usually a euphemism for “your cartoons are hitting the bourgeoisie a bit to truthfully.” Bela champions the truth as he understands it and never shies away from revealing it in his work. He is a champion of the “self” and refuses in every “scene” of his life to surrender that self to anyone or to anything. Bela “does not like the world” but gives his life to expose its deleterious underbelly.

Under Richard Romagnoli’s taut and considered direction, each member of the ensemble cast of “No End of Blame” delivers powerfully authentic performances. The principals – in addition to Mr. Draper – include David Barlow as Belas’s friend Grigor, Stephanie Janssen as Ilona, Valerie Leonard as Stella (and others), Christopher Marshall as the 2nd Comrade (and others), and Jonathan Tindle as Hoogstraten (and others). The remainder of the ensemble cast all bring honest performances and give their characters depth and believability.

Although “No End of Blame” focuses specifically on the life of the artist, Bela’s conflicts resonate profoundly with Everyman’s ennui and angst and the extended metaphors of this important play counterpoint the oppressive political environment extant currently in the United States (and beyond). Only one caveat: Howard Barker’s words are so powerful, so incisive, one must listen carefully and be sure not to miss a moment of the action they generate on stage.


The cast for “No End of Blame: Scenes of Overcoming” includes David Barlow, Alexander Burnett, Alex Draper, Ashley Fink, Christo Grabowski, Shannon Gibbs, Nicholas Hemerling, Stephanie Janssen, Valerie Leonard, Christopher Marshall, Steven Medina, Gabrielle Owens, and Jonathan Tindle.

The production team includes Hallie Zieselman (Set Design), Mark Evancho (Lighting Design), Danielle Nieves (Costume Design), Gerald Scarfe (Cartoon Projections) and Eric Conner Marlin (Production Stage Manager). Production photos by Stan Barouh.

Performances are Tuesdays - Sundays at 7:00 p.m., and Wednesdays, Saturdays and Sundays at 2:00 p.m. The schedule varies - for exact days and times visit Tickets are $35.00, $20.00 for students and seniors, and can be purchased online at or by calling 1-866-811-4111. For info visit, follow on Twitter at @ptpnyc, and Like them on Facebook at Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes including one intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, July 15, 2016

Off-Broadway Review: “The Annotated History of the American Muskrat” at Ice Factory 2016 at the New Ohio Theatre (Through Saturday July 16, 2016)

Photo: (R-L) Madeline Boles, Sam Bell-Gurwitz, Anna Nemetz, Simon Henriques, Christopher Fitzsimmons, Molly Jones, Justin Phillips, and Jared Bellot. Credit: Cheno Pinter.
Off-Broadway Review: “The Annotated History of the American Muskrat” at Ice Factory 2016 at the New Ohio Theatre (Through Saturday July 16, 2016)
Written by John Kuntz
Directed by Skylar Fox
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“I want us to start over. I don’t want to fight any more. I don’t want to be angry, all the time. I just want us to be happy, just you and me. No one else.” – Patsy to Trevor, Part 3 “And a garden [for our two dogs] to play in.” – Trevor to Patsy, Part 3

There are very few who would argue with Patsy (Anna Nemetz) that seeking redemption and release from the world’s pain – specifically America’s apparent long-term dysfunctional state – would be a very good thing. And few would take umbrage at Trevor’s (Simon Henriques) suggestion that a retreat to Voltaire’s “tending one’s own garden” might be one source of surcease from the center not holding in the land of the brave.

Foxy Henriques and Circuit Theatre have decided to resurrect their 2014 production of John Kuntz’s “The Annotated History of the American Muskrat,” currently running at Ice Factory 2016 at the New Ohio Theatre, to address the nation’s perennial brokenness. In a series of “Saturday Night Live” skits loosely structured around several through stories (the muskrat experiment, Trevor (Simon Henriques) and Patsy (Anna Nemetz) and others) playwright John Kuntz utilizes an extended metaphor counterpointing the escapades of eight muskrats with the history of the United States.

The skits include conversations between Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger, Pat Nixon (Justin Phillips) and Betty Ford (Molly Jones), Daryl Dragon and Toni Tennille, the “Pilgrims” and the Original Americans and “appearances” from Queen Elizabeth II (Sam Bell-Gurwitz), Little Debbie, Mary Todd Lincoln, President Gerald Ford (Jared Bellot), and Jane Pierce – to name but a few.

All of this chicanery is – or is not – meant to expose the questionable underbelly of the history of America and perhaps – or not – challenge the audience to rethink history in a new way. The audience is also challenged to explore “Big Brother” in different ways. Who is watching whom? And where does the string of “watchers” begin or end?

Of the many “skits,” two stand out – one because of its cleverness and the other because of its relevance. The retelling of the Iroquois creation myth is marvelous. Teharonhiawako, creator of the Earth, depends on the diving skills of the muskrat to retrieve the matter needed to complete creation. The ensemble cast does well here and handily engage the audience in the muskiness of mythos. And when Trevor (Simon Henriques) and Patsy (Madeline Boles) pressure Keith (Jared Bellot) to rehearse “The History of Black People in America,” the audience falls into attentive and blessed silence for the first and only time throughout the otherwise laugh-track-filled time.

The rest – most from the precarious American 1970s – work too hard for laughs. If the Circuit Theatre is hoping to re-connect audiences with the foibles of America in the hopes of redemption or at least catharsis, then silliness needs to be balanced with thoughtful exposition. Even if the Company has no agenda at all – and there’s not necessarily anything wrong with that – there needs to be some purpose in asking the audience to sit through almost three hours of flying feathers, gales of glitter, Little Debbie treats (why weren’t those sold at the concession stand?), and a frenzy of farce.

That said, if the revival of “The Annotated History of the American Muskrat” fosters a discussion about the serious racial divide in the United States and the serious deterioration of individual rights, the endeavor is worth the effort. Only two of Ice Factory 2016 shows are open to press for review. See the schedule below for the remaining shows in performance through August 13.


The cast of “The Annotated History” includes Sam Bell-Gurwitz, Jared Bellot, Madeline Boles, Christopher Fitzsimmons, Simon Henriques, Molly Jones, Anna Nemetz, and Justin Phillips.

The production team includes Scenic Design by Adam Wyron, Costume Design by Corina Chase, Lighting Design by Christopher Annas-Lee, Props Design by Amalia Sweet, Production Stage Manager Lida Richardson, and Executive Produced by Jenny Gorelick. Produced in association with Foxy Henriques, The Circuit Theatre Company, and The Ice Factory Festival at New Ohio Theatre. Production photos by Cheno Pinter.

Performances are at New Ohio Theatre at 154 Christopher St. on Wednesday July 13 at 7:00 p.m., Thursday July 14 at 7:00 p.m., Friday July 15 at 7:00 p.m., and Saturday July 16 at 7:00 p.m.

Tickets are available at or by calling 212-352-3101. Tickets are $18.00 general admission and $15.00 for students and seniors. For the full Ice Factory 2016 lineup, visit Follow the muskrats on twitter @foxyhenriques. For more information about Foxy Henriques, visit Running time is 3 hours including two 10-minute intermissions.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, July 14, 2016

Review: “Good” Grapples with Evil at PTP/NYC 2016 at Atlantic Stage 2 (Through Sunday August 7, 2016)

Photo: Michael Kaye and Adam Ludwig. Credit: Stan Barouh.
Review: “Good” Grapples with Evil at PTP/NYC 2016 at Atlantic Stage 2 (Through Sunday August 7, 2016)
By C. P. Taylor
Directed by Jim Petosa
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“In short, it is much easier to see a thing through from the point of view of abstract principle than from that of concrete responsibility.” ¯ Dietrich Bonhoeffer, “Letters and Papers from Prison”

When under stress, Professor John Halder (Michael Kaye) hears songs of comfort that no one else can hear. Numbed by fantasy fueled by denial – like many “good” people during the rise of Nazism in post-World War I Germany – Halder refuses to understand the menace of Hitler’s racialist programs and colludes with Hitler’s regime believing because “Hitler’s racialist program is not practical they’ll have to drop it.” “They” do not drop it and exterminate over six million Jews and other members of humankind the Nazis deem undesirable.

C. P. Taylor’s important and dauntingly relevant “Good,” currently running at PTP/NYC 2016 at Atlantic Stage 2, chronicles how this good person Professor Halder becomes an ally of all that is not good about Nazi Germany. It is a compelling and engaging look into the dynamics of delusional behavior and how easy it is to do the wrong thing in times of crisis. Throughout the play, Halder slowly begins to face reality until, when he finally visits Auschwitz, the music he hears – no longer in his head – is played by those ready to be exterminated.

No matter how much Halder’s Jewish friend Maurice (Tim Spears) tries to dissuade Halder from supporting “abstract principles” and to instead embrace “concrete responsibility,” Halder spirals further into delusion and condones Eichmann’s (Adam Ludwig) “common interest” point of view. The more the regime asks him to participate in their “mercy killing” experiments, the easier it becomes for him to comply – matching the music in his head, his delusional understanding of the evils of Hitler and the SS.

The Nazis become interested in Halder after discovering his novel that deals with euthanasia, a concept that fascinates Halder as he watches his mother (Judith Chaffee) decline into the depths of dementia and becomes more as more difficult to care for. At one point Halder’s mother asks, “Do you think I’m going out of my mind? If I’m going out of my mind. . .that’s a bad business.” Additionally, Halder’s center is not holding well as he drifts from his wife Helen (Valerie Leonard) and takes up with Anne one of his students at the University (Caitlin Rose Duffy).

Under Jim Petosa’s deft direction, the ensemble cast grapples successfully with Mr. Taylor’s script to reveal important themes that raise rich and enduring questions that are as relevant currently as they were in the past. When does self-interest conflict with interest in the common good? Which is more important to the individual? What are neuroses and how do these affect one’s performance in the service of the public? What is reality for politicians? What happens when “their” reality is pathological? What exactly is the difference between good and evil? What is good? What is evil? Mr. Petosa’s staging effectively collides reality with illusion with scenes that collide into one another with gripping ferocity.

Mark Evancho’s set and Hallie Zieselman’s lighting mirror the caverns of Halder’s mind and Jessica Vankempen’s costumes are period perfect and hauntingly realistic. PTP/NYC’s Co-Artistic Director Cheryl Faraone introduces “Good” with the hope “the work will become part of [our] conversation” about the current political and socio-economic environment where – as in the early 1930s – the center is not holding and where again “it [has become] much easier to see a thing through from the point of view of abstract principle than from that of concrete responsibility.” Audiences have only through August 7 to see “Good” at Atlantic Stage 2. It would be fascinating to see “Good” played in repertory with Aaron Loeb’s “Ideation.”


The cast for “Good” includes Michael Kaye, Tim Spears, Valerie Leonard, Christo Grabowski, Judith Chafee, Adam Ludwig, Noah Berman, Caitlin Rose Duffy, Amanda Whiteley and Jesse Garlick.

The production team includes Hallie Zieselman (Set Design), Mark Evancho (Lighting Design), Jessica Lee Vankempen (Costume Design) and Evangeline Rose Whitlock (Production Stage Manager). Production photos by Stan Barouh.

Performances are Tuesdays - Sundays at 7:00 p.m., and Wednesdays, Saturdays and Sundays at 2:00 p.m. The schedule varies - for exact days and times visit Tickets are $35.00, $20.00 for students and seniors, $17.50 for previews, and can be purchased online at or by calling 1-866-811-4111. For info visit, follow on Twitter at @ptpnyc, and Like them on Facebook at Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes including a 10-minute intermission.
214 Comments - Read Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Review: “Are We Human” at Ice Factory 2016 at The New Ohio Theatre (Through Saturday July 9, 2016)

Photo: Matthew Bretschneider and Alexandra Lemus. Credit Benjamin Heller.
Review: “Are We Human” at Ice Factory 2016 at The New Ohio Theatre (Through Saturday July 9, 2016)
Written by John Kaplan
Directed by Margarett Perry
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“Please try to remember that what they believe, as well as what they do and cause you to endure does not testify to your inferiority but to their inhumanity” ¯ James Baldwin, “The Fire Next Time”

Whether or not we are truly human has been in question since one of the two Judeo-Christian creation myths sported Adam and Eve no longer naked expulsed from the Garden of Eden. Humankind – now fallen – continues to fare poorly in the “being human” quest as it wanders aimlessly in its new East of Eden home.

Humankind’s fall from grace and its grappling with the enduring question, “Are We Human,” is the subject – the main subject – of Ice Factory 2016’s/Universal Bellows’ new play of the same name currently playing at The New Ohio Theatre.

In the play, those in power – led by Mr. Algorithm (Bradford Cover) strive to keep down the android revolution and maintain the superiority of the “humans.” Ethan (Matthew Bretschneider) and Violet (Alexandra Lemus) lead the charge to save the androids and bring down Mr. Android. Are they prophets? Saviors? There is much soteriology in the script as well as allusions to Broadway shows, songs, and other cultural ephemera. One also needs to be wary of “that man behind the curtain” who poses as the Creator. It is all quite complicated – not complex – and often abstruse. Too much esoterica a good play does not always make.

John Kaplan’s “Are We Human” feels like an Integrated Feeling Therapy session and there is nothing wrong with that. At its best, “Are We Human” is an allegory that focuses on the racial divide in the United States. Unfortunately, this important focus fades in the matrix of themes playwright Kaplan chooses to address. Why would such an important theme be shuffled with concerns about the relevance of theatre or the fourth wall? When the play does manage to refocus, nothing new is offered. The haves, the privileged, the “humans,” the ones for whom the almighty algorithm has been designed oppress the have nots, the androids, the ones who merely “serve” the almighty algorithm. The trope – here the extended metaphor – is clear.

What is not clear is how the extended metaphor supports the play’s themes. Just as a workable algorithm leads to the solution of complex problems. So should tropes lead the audience to a satisfying and cathartic resolution of conflicts. Despite the work of the talented cast and the efforts of director Margarett Perry, “Are We Human” leaves the audience hoping for more. In addition to those mentioned earlier, the cast includes James Davies (Bartender), Karl Gregory (Guy) and Alex Sunderhaus (Rosy).

David Arsenault’s off-kilter sci-fi set is brilliant. Jon Levin’s expensive props, although easy on the eye, often fail to work properly at the most unfortunate times. See the information below for the complete Ice Factory 2016 program.


The cast of “Are We Human” features Matthew Bretschneider, Bradford Cover, James Davies, Karl Gregory, Alexandra Lemus, and Alex Sunderhaus. The creative team includes David L. Arsenault (scenic and lighting design), Amanda Aiken (costume design), Nate Goebel (sound design), and Jon Levin (prop design). Katy Moore is production stage manager. Production photos by Benjamin Heller.

Performances are Wednesdays - Saturdays at 7pm. Tickets are $18, and $15 for students and seniors, and can be purchased online at or by calling 212-352-3101. For info visit, like on Facebook at /NewOhioTheatre and /IceFactoryFestival, follow on Instagram at NewOhioTheatre, and for up-to-the-minute festival updates follow on Twitter at @NewOhioTheatre. Running time 100 minutes without intermission.
2 Comments - Read Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, July 8, 2016

Review: “On Your Feet!” at The Marquis Theatre (Open Run)

Cast of "On Your Feet!" - Photo by Matthew Murphy
Review: “On Your Feet!” at The Marquis Theatre (Open Run)
Book by Alexander Dinelaris
Featuring Music Produced and Recorded by Emilio and Gloria Estefan and the Miami Sound Machine
Directed by Jerry Mitchell
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Exactly how easy is it to get up on one’s feet after a significant life challenge? “On Your Feet!,” currently playing at the Marquis Theatre, addresses this enduring question by focusing on the lives and successful careers of Emilio and Gloria Estefan. The musical follows Gloria’s flight from Cuba’s Revolution, to meeting Emilio while in college in the United States, to the 1991 American Music Awards where Gloria celebrated her first public performance following her serious bus accident in 1990.

Although “On Your Feet!” features a book by Alexander Dinelaris, it is really an engaging jukebox musical that depends heavily on the music of the Estefans and the Miami Sound Machine to tell the story of the iconic couple. The musical highlights several important themes and raises a considerable collection of rich and enduring questions. How does one decide between one’s passion and the demanding expectations of one’s close relatives? In Gloria’s case, her mother does not support Gloria’s love for performance but her grandmother insists that Gloria not sacrifice her dreams for a more “stable” career.

Gloria’s mother thought Gloria – like her sister – should continue to pursue her academic career and help the family care for Gloria’s bedridden father. When does commitment to family require one to abandon one’s own needs and future?

Once in America and enjoying success in the Spanish-speaking market, Emilio wanted Gloria to be able to crossover to a wider English-speaking audience. Their agents were not interested in a crossover career for Gloria and Emilio had to become proactive to make this part of their dream possible. As a result, Gloria is often considered to be the first successful crossover performer to date. In the process, Emilio is able to break racial and cultural stereotypes, at one-point proclaiming to a doubting agent, “This is what an American looks like!”

Unfortunately, the Playbill does not include the names of the songs or the scenes in the musical. Quite frankly, this oversight is simply puzzling. However, among the songs, these are not only memorable but drive the plot of the musical forward: “When Someone Comes into Your Life;” “If I Never Got to Tell You;” “Don’t Wanna Lose You;” “Coming Out of the Dark;” and the powerful “Mega Mix” at the curtain call.

Under Jerry Mitchell’s able direction, the cast is uniformly brilliant. Stand out performances are those by Ana Villafne (Gloria), Josh Segarra (Emilio), Andrea Burns (Gloria Fajardo), Alma Cuervo (Consuelo), and Eliseo Roman (Jose Fajardo). Mr. Fajardo delivers an authentic performance as Gloria’s father and Mr. Segarra will be missed after July 12, 2016. His unassuming performance as Estefan is perhaps the emotional core of the entire ensemble cast.

David Rockwell’s set is splendid as is Kenneth Posner’s lighting. ESosa’s costumes are time and place appropriate and stunning to watch in motion. Sergio Trujillo’s choreography is brilliant, especially the over-the-top tap number in sandals!

“On Your Feet!” will be around for some time. Enjoy the music and the story and be inspired.


Ana Villafañe and Josh Segarra star as Gloria and Emilio Estefan. The cast also features Andréa Burns as Gloria Fajardo (Gloria’s mother), Alma Cuervo as Consuelo (Gloria’s grandmother), Alexandria Suarez as Little Gloria, Eduardo Hernandez as Nayib/Young Emilio, Fabi Aguirre, Karmine Alers, Yassmin Alers, David Baida, Natalie Caruncho, Henry Gainza, Linedy Genao, Carlos E. Gonzalez, Nina Lafarga, Genny Lis Padilla, Omar Lopez-Cepero, Hector Maisonet, Marielys Molina, Felix Monge, Doreen Montalvo, Liz Ramos, Eliseo Roman, Luis Salgado, Marcos Santana, Martín Solá, Jennifer Sanchez, Brett Sturgis, Kevin Tellez, Eric Ulloa, Tanairi Vasquez and Lee Zarrett. Ektor Rivera will assume the role of Emilio Estefan beginning July 12, 2016. This will be Mr. Rivera’s Broadway debut.

“On Your Feet!” is choreographed by Sergio Trujillo. Completing the creative team are Scenic Designer David Rockwell, Costume Designer Emilio Sosa, Lighting Designer Kenneth Posner Sound Designer Steve Kennedy, Projections by Darrel Maloney, and Hair and Wig Designer Chuck LaPointe. With Music Direction by Lon Hoyt, Orchestrations by Gloria Estefan and Emilio Estefan, Dance Arrangements and Dance Orchestrations by Oscar Hernandez, the “On Your Feet!” Orchestra will include several members of Miami Sound Machine. Production photos by Matthew Murphy.

Broadway tickets are now on sale via For groups of 12+, call: 212-840-3890 or 800-714-8451. For more information, including performance schedule and ticket prices, please visit Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes including one intermission.
2 Comments - Read Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, June 29, 2016

Review: “On The Verge” at the Attic Theater Company at Walkerspace (Through Saturday July 9, 2016)

(L to R) Ella Dershowitz, Monette Magrath, Emily Kitchens, and William John Austin. Credit: Natalie Artemyeff.
Review: “On The Verge” at the Attic Theater Company at Walkerspace (Through Saturday July 9, 2016)
By Eric Overmyer
Directed by Laura Braza
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

In the Attic Theater Company’s production of Eric Overmyer’s démodé “On The Verge,” currently playing at Walkerspace, three women venture forth from the relative safety of late nineteenth-century Terra Haute, Indiana to explore the unknown realms of Terra Incognita. Although it is not entirely certain what provides the source of their motivation for wanderlust, they seem ready to move on from all things “home.” Fanny’s (Emily Kitchens) roots in Terra Haute are shallow: her marriage is less than satisfying and she does not even know who the current President is. Alex (Ella Dershowitz) finds the mores of her environment stifling and always wears a pair of pants under her dress – just in case. And Mary (Monette Magrath) has the innate yearning for the future that eventually keeps her on the path of discovery.

It is not long into their journey into Terra Incognita that It becomes clear this is more a spiritual and “imaginary” journey rather than a physical excursion, thus providing a possible rich connection to the current political, economic, and social upheaval in America and across the globe. The women begin to channel images from the future and struggle with having to “accept the future” without “embracing it.” However, because the trio ends up in 1955 via chronokinesis, the imagery in the script seems dated and not as readily attainable as it needs to be for a 2016 audience.

Mr. Overmyer’s language-based script becomes overburdened with alliterative plays on words and other common literary devices and – after time – waxes somewhat tiresome. His writing is not akin to Tennessee Williams’ or Edward Albee’s rich use of language; rather, it seems more like an exercise in freshman composition rhetoric. This is unfortunate since the playwright’s message about engaging the future while negotiating the accoutrements of our collective pasts (histories) is an important one.

Both acts are overly long and the second wobbles off base quickly after Scene 18 “Woody’s Esso.” The actors grapple with their characters in a heroic fashion and traverse their psyches with the same bravado and skill utilized in the imaginary journey to Terra Incognita. Unfortunately, there are occasions when the three capable actors seem to lose their footing. Perhaps director Laura Braza needs to provide more support in these scenes going forward. William John Austin capably portrays the various characters the women encounter on their journey and his ability to “find” these characters differs not on his craft but on what the script gives him to work with.

Julia Noulin-Merat’s multi-purpose set and Daniel B. Chapman’s lighting function well for the most part; however, there are places on set where the lighting truss framework is balanced on lighting cable causing the actors to lose balance. Emily Rosenberg’s costumes are delightful and appropriate to each period “visited.”

Laura Barza’s apologia for choosing to “dust off” Mr. Overmyer’s play is heartfelt and understandable. One wonders though if a different play might more honestly and helpfully address the nation’s – and the world’s – stark realization that in the current “second coming” things are falling apart, the center cannot hold, and “mere anarchy is loosed upon the world.” Where is William Butler Yeats when he is needed most? Eric Overmyer’s 1985 – though counterpointing the present in many ways – is far from the oppressive angst of the world’s current population and his message seems to ring with a naïve innocence.

We need to “dream in a new language” just not the language extant in “On the Verge.” That said, the Attic Theater Company’s annual trek to New York City is always welcomed and Ms. Braza’s vision is worthy of the theatregoer’s ongoing support.


The cast of “On The Verge” features William John Austin as Grover, Ella Dershowitz as Alex, Emily Kitchens as Fanny, and Monette Magrath as Mary.

“On The Verge” has scenic design by Julia Noulin-Merat, costume design by Emily Rosenberg, lighting design by Daniel B. Chapman, and sound design by Beth Lake. The casting director is Judy Bowman, CSA.
“On The Verge” is presented by The Attic Theater Company, produced by Ted Caine and Noelle Franco. Production photos by Natalie Artemyeff.

“On The Verge” runs at Walkerspace (46 Walker Street, NYC) through Saturday, July 9th. The regular performance schedule is: Tuesday through Saturday at 7:00 p.m. and Sunday at 5:00 p.m. (Dark on Mondays). There will be additional Saturday matinee performances on July 9th at 3:00 p.m. There will be no performance on Sunday, July 3rd.

Tickets for “On The Verge” are priced at $25.00 and are on sale now via Smart Tix. For online purchases go to!upcoming/c6v5. Running time is 2hours and 10 minutes with a 15-minute intermission.
3 Comments - Read Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Saturday, June 25, 2016

Review: “A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Gynecologic Oncology Unit at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center of New York City Teases the Psyche at the Lucille Lortel Theatre

Beth Behrs, Lisa Emery, Jacqueline Sydney, and Erik Lochtefeld in a scene from "A Funny Thing..." Photo by Matthew Murphy
Review: “A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Gynecologic Oncology Unit at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center of New York City Teases the Psyche at the Lucille Lortel Theatre
By Halley Feiffer
Directed by Trip Cullman
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

If the title of Halley Feiffer’s new play “A Funny Thing Happened…” has any relevance – and this critic believes all titles are chosen for a specific purpose – then what happens before the audience meets Karla (Beth Behrs) and Don (Erik Lochtefeld) must be important. Otherwise, why borrow this great vaudevillian line? On the way to visiting their mothers at Memorial Sloan Kettering’s Gynecological Oncology Unit, star-crossed lovers Karla and Don have carried around considerable psychological baggage which they begin to unpack when they meet across the divide of the privacy curtain separating their mothers’ beds.

Karla is a stand-up comic pitching her new comedic bits to her bed-ridden mother. Her sexually graphic comedy writing serves a variety of purposes both protective and portentous. Don is recovering from a divorce from the wife who has discovered her true sexual status and reeling from his apparently failed attempts at parenting his estranged son Malcolm who has hacked into Don’s bank account and withdrawn three thousand dollars. When Don walks in and hears Karla talking about rape and her vibrator, his venting soon follows resulting in a barrage of Millennial madness from the other side of the closed curtain. What follows is akin to a speed dating event gone very wrong.

Part of the success of “A Funny Thing…” is Ms. Feiffer’s judicious use of literary tropes including sophisticated threads of symbolism and sparkling imagery. It is no accident the setting is a hospital room designated for the rehearsal of death and dying. The intergenerational pair collides, bonds, and begins the long process of bereavement as their chance encounter begins to peel away layers of hurt and mistrust to reveal cores of honest grappling with mortality. Ms. Feiffer’s script allows the characters to engage in repeated volleys of assault and disarmament that result in millennial bravura being transformed into an intergenerational truce.

The extended sex scene in the bathroom of the hospital room is less about the salacious “event” and more about the two seemingly mismatched strangers – in age, gender, economic status – attaining parity and breaking down the barriers that society has imposed on them and which they have accepted as normative.

Under Trip Cullman’s judicious and incisive direction, Mr. Lochtefeld and Ms. Behrs both deliver convincing and authentic performances each capturing the complexities of their characters’ lives. Karla’s mother Marcie (played with a chilling disinterest by Lisa Emery) and Don’s mother Geena (played with a powerful silence by Jacqueline Sydney) remain bedridden throughout but their strength is evident in the collateral damage their parenting has inflicted. Ms. Emery’s character’s late attempts at reconciliation with her daughter come across as disingenuous although reconciliation has always been a tricky business.

Lauren Helpern’s uber-realistic hospital room counterpoints the onstage battles for healthy separation and individuation and is complemented by Kaye Voyce’s costume design, Matthew Richards’ clever lighting design, and Darron L. West’s sound design.

Halley Feiffer’s new play is worth the visit to MCC Theater’s home at the Lucille Lortel Theatre in Manhattan’s West Village.


The cast of “A Funny Thing Happened…” includes Beth Behrs, Lisa Emery, Erik Lochtefeld, and Jacqueline Sydney. The design team includes sets by Lauren Helpern, costumes by Kaye Voyce, lighting by Matthews Richards, and sound by Darron L West. Production photos by Matthew Murphy.

For performance schedule and to purchase tickets, please visit Running time is 90 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, June 23, 2016

Review: “Out of the Mouths of Babes” at the Cherry Lane Theatre (Through Sunday August 31, 2016)

Judith Ivey and Estelle Parsons in "Out of the Mouths of Babes." Credit: Carol Rosegg
Review: “Out of the Mouths of Babes” at the Cherry Lane Theatre (Through Sunday August 31, 2016)
By Israel Horovitz
Directed by Barnet Kellman
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Marie-Belle (played with a coy bravado by Francesca Choy-Kee) is the last wife of the recently deceased one-hundred-year-old man who – though unnamed – could easily be the protagonist of Israel Horovitz’s new play “Out of the Mouths of Babes” currently playing at the Cherry Lane Theatre. After his death, Marie-Belle invites two of her husband’s former wives-lovers to the Paris apartment where they all spent years with the man who taught at the Sorbonne and who collected lovers and wives like art to excess. Joining Evelyn (played with a stoic vulnerability by Estelle Parsons) and Evvie (played with jilted indifference by Judith Ivey) is former wife Janice (played with clever innocence by Angelina Fiordellisi) who, though not invited, learns of her former husband’s death in the obituaries. It is out of the mouths of these innocents that the audience learns who they are, why they are there, what they thought of the deceased, and how their American views on love and marriage differ from those of their French host Marie-Belle.

Israel Horovitz’s new play is the perfect platform for these four actors. Think Susan Harris’s television sit-com “The Golden Girls” on steroids. Mr. Horovitz is a prolific writer with many successful projects to his credit. This new play allows acting to trump writing with or without intention on the part of the playwright. It is enough to say that with a different cast – and this one is stellar – the piece might not make it past the first act.

Evelyn, Evvie, and Janice banter, bicker, brag, bargain, and often betray their true feelings of abandonment and their mistrust of the newest young French wife who seems to be able to transcend all of their sexual conquests and hang-ups with her stories of openness in relationships and sexual freedom. The exchanges are often quite funny but because the object of their affection was seemingly such a scoundrel, it all falls rather flat. If he was as feckless as their stories reveal, a dip in the canal below the apartment would be a refreshing escape throughout the decades of his decadence.

Estelle Parsons, Judith Ivey, and Angelina Fiordellisi turn the “everyone comes clean” scene late into the second act into an irreverent group confessional with each, in turn, presiding as the recalcitrant priest offering fragments of forgiveness. Francesca Choy-Kee transforms Mr. Horovitz’s magical realism into delightful comedic fare.

Under Barnet Kellman’s sit-com direction – and there’s nothing wrong with a good sit-com – the stellar cast keeps everything moving throughout although when Mr. Horovitz’s script begins to wobble to far too the magical, the acting has a more difficult time rising to the surface. Neil Patel’s set is portrait-perfect and arguably among the best use of the performance space at the Cherry Lane Theatre main stage. Joseph G. Aulisi’s costumes are splendid and wear well dry, wet, or slightly damaged from a fall into an open grave (guess who?). Paul Miller’s lighting design works well with Leon Rothenber’s sound design to complement the setting for this new play. Watch for the delicious subtle lighting changes throughout the evening.

“Out of the Mouths of Babes” gives the audience the rare opportunity to see the highest caliber of acting all in one sumptuously decorated package. How could this not be worth the visit?


The creative team for “Out of the Mouths of Babes includes scenic design by Neil Patel, costume design by Joseph G. Aulisi, lighting design by Paul Miller, and sound design by Leon Rothenberg. Production photos by

For performance and ticket information go to or call OvationTix at 866-8111-4111 or in person at the Cherry Lane box office at 38 Commerce Street in Manhattan’s West Village. Running time is 2 hours and 5 minutes including a 15-minute intermission.

WITH: Francesca Choy-Kee, Angelina Fiordellisi, Judith Ivey, and Estelle Parsons.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, June 20, 2016

Review: "Fragments of Marilyn" at the Laurie Beechman Theatre

Review: “Fragments of Marilyn” at the Laurie Beechman Theatre
With Marissa Mulder
Directed by Sondra Lee
Musical Direction by Jon Weber
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

“Fragments of Marilyn” is much more a theater piece than a cabaret show as presented at the Laurie Beechman Theater by the talented actor/singer Marissa Mulder. It can be described as a stream of consciousness monologue interrupted by splinters of musical numbers with lyrics that reveal the hurt and pain of one of the most famous of Hollywood idols. These may be fragments of the complicated movie star icon but by the end of the disjointed hour, Ms. Mulder prevails in creating the emotional whole of an often misconstrued and broken woman. She merely alludes to the people who surrounded her life and contributed to the misery with no names and no blame, but with an outpouring of what the situations made her realize and feel. She is intelligent, wise, vulnerable, depressed, and angry with the soul of a child trapped inside the body of a woman, which is the one attribute she trusts and uses to capture success. It is not an easy show to watch or perform. It is not about the sexy, blonde bombshell image that seized the public eye. It is a peek at the abuse, abandonment, loneliness and fear as well as a celebration of the resilience to survive as divulged in the writings of a candid celebrity, worshiped by the masses but incapable of being loved.

Early on we hear a revealing rendition of “It’s Only a Paper Moon” exposing the shallow emptiness and glamorous façade of the Hollywood she embraced. A rendition of “Don’t Rain On My Parade” releases the anger, persistence and determination needed to defeat those who tried to control her life. One of the most telling closing musical numbers is “Hurt” which accentuates her despair and acceptance of being lonely and alone. Ms. Mulder does not look or for that matter sound like the infamous persona but she embodies and amazingly becomes the unmitigated Marilyn Monroe, blemishes and all. Her voice is clear, powerful and penetrating as she discovers a full range of emotions to translate the lyrics. She mesmerizes the audience, is fascinating to watch and a joy to hear. If there is a chance to catch this remarkable piece of cabaret theater in the future, don’t hesitate, not one moment will disappoint.


“Fragments of Marilyn” ran at the Laurie Beechman Theatre through Friday June 17, 2016. For more information about the Laurie Beechman Theatre, please visit
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Sunday, June 19, 2016

Review: “Shining City” at the Irish Repertory Theatre (Through Sunday July 3, 2016)

Matthew Broderick and Billy Carter in "Shining City." Photo by Carol Rosegg.
Review: “Shining City” at the Irish Repertory Theatre (Through Sunday July 3, 2016)
By Conor McPherson
Directed by Ciarán O’Reilly
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“And how stands the city on this winter night? More prosperous, more secure, and happier than it was 8 years ago. But more than that: After 200 years, two centuries, she still stands strong and true on the granite ridge, and her glow has held steady no matter what storm. And she's still a beacon, still a magnet for all who must have freedom, for all the pilgrims from all the lost places who are hurtling through the darkness, toward home.” (Ronald Reagan’s “Shining City Upon A Hill” Farewell Speech, January 11 1989)

America in the late 1980s was for Ronald Reagan a shining city upon a hill, “a magnet for all who must have freedom.” This nation was pristine, flawless, offering to all who would respond to its beckoning the opportunity for improvement, self-discovery, and community. Many nation-states and their urban centers offer similar promises to the “pilgrims from lost places who are hurtling through darkness, toward home.” John (Matthew Broderick), Ian (Billy Carter), Neasa (Lisa Dawn), and Laurence (James Russell) are four such pilgrims navigating Dublin’s promises in Conor McPherson’s “Shining City” currently running at the newly renovated Irish Repertory Company.

James Joyce wrote, "For myself, I always write about Dublin, because if I can get to the heart of Dublin I can get to the heart of all the cities of the world. In the particular is contained the universal." Conor McPherson has accomplished the same goal in his “Shining City.” The stories told here are universal stories of self-discovery, motivation, fear, loneliness, and making choices – for better or for worse. Stories of recognizing opportunities to “sort out” life’s challenges and unexpected changes.

John has been seeing the ghost of his deceased wife Mari in their house and, thinking he might be a “nutcase,” he visits psychotherapist Ian to “sort it all out.” John is former priest Ian’s first client and – as the audience learns – the roles of penitent and priest and client and therapist often become reversed in Mr. McPherson’s engaging and complex script. John’s confessional sessions reveal a lonely individual who rarely communicated with his wife before her fatal accident. Those sessions somehow give Ian permission to admit to his girlfriend Neasa it might be time to part ways.

“Shining City” features three (at least) parallel stories, parallel situations and conflicts involving dyads of human interaction without authentic human connection. There is no communication between John and his wife; none between Ian and his girlfriend Neasa; and initially even less between John and Laurence the sex worker John turns to for comfort and understanding. In these parallel stories, the characters discover communication and non-judgmental affirmation from very unexpected places.

Under Ciarán O’Reilly’s meticulous and clean direction, the cast of “Shining City” captures the full range of human emotions including those often roiling beneath the surface waiting to offer redemption and release if expressed. Matthew Broderick gives his character John a sensitive believability that is expressed in dialogue and in lengthy monologues. Mr. Broderick give’s John’s journey from fear to courage authenticity. Billy Carter portrays Ian with a graceful underbelly of frustration and guilt unable to fully disengage from his dysfunctional relationship with Neasa. Lisa Dwan’s Neasa is manipulative, fearful, and determined not to allow Ian to separate from her and their child. And James Russell portrays a young man ravaged by poverty and unemployment to work in places he never expected to labor.

Charlie Corcoran has designed a clean and serviceable set that allows the actors to settle into their roles with ease and comfort. Sven Henry Nelson’s property design creates the illusion of not only the passing of time but the growth of the characters. Martha Hally’s costumes, Michael Gottlieb’s lighting, and M. Florian Staab’s sound successfully complement the action of the play.

During their first session, Ian tells John he sees the ghost of his wife because he needs to. That might be true but one wonders whether Mari’s ghost had its final appearance in the couple’s bathroom. Only time will tell.


The cast of “Shining City” features Matthew Broderick, Bill Carter, Lisa Dwan, and James Russell.

‘Shining City” features scenic design by Charlie Corcoran, costume design by Martha Hally, lighting design by Michael Gottlieb, and sound design by Ryan Rumery. Production photos by Carol Rosegg.

“Shining City” plays a strictly limited engagement through Sunday, July 3rd at the newly renovated Irish Repertory Theatre (132 West 22nd Street). Performances are Tuesday and Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday at 8:00 p.m.; Wednesday, Saturday, and Sunday matinees at 3:00 p.m. Tickets are $50.00 - $70.00 and available here: Running time is 90 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, June 9, 2016

Review: “Hero’s Welcome” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Saturday July 2, 2016)

L-R: Evelyn Hoskins and Richard Stacey in Hero’s Welcome, written and directed by Alan Ayckbourn, part of Brits Off Broadway at 59E59 Theaters. Photo by Tony Bartholomew.
Review: “Hero’s Welcome” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Saturday July 2, 2016)
Written and Directed by Alan Ayckbourn
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

In Alan Ayckbourn’s new play “Hero’s Welcome,” currently running at 59E59 Theaters at part of the Brits Off Broadway Series, a young British soldier returns home from military conflict for the first time in seventeen years. Murray (Richard Stacey) brings his new bride Baba (Evelyn Hoskins) back to his former home to start a new life and restore the hotel once owned by his parents. Although he is greeted as a hero, there are residents who are not pleased about his return and collude to send him and Baba packing.

“Hero’s Welcome” is replete with deceit, revenge, and intrigue. Once the play’s exposition is established, each character and her or his conflicts drive an interesting but often predictable plot. Before he skipped town seventeen years ago, Murray was part of a love triangle with Alice (played with a vengeful remorse by Elizabeth Boag) and Kara (played with a simmering self-awareness by Charlotte Harwood) – a tryst that ended in an unwanted pregnancy and a bride left at the altar. Although both women have since married, fractured feelings remain and neither woman wants Murray around.

Mr. Ayckbourn’s new play is decidedly character driven and the actors (as in “Confusions”) are the key elements of the production’s success. Richard Stacey understands Murray’s problems completely and portrays the homecoming soldier with the right balance of bravura and hometown boy charm. His scenes opposite Evelyn Hoskins (Baba) are powerful and Ms. Hoskins counterpoints Mr. Stacey’s bravado with emotional strength: she is a spiritual spitfire and he wears his secret like a tight-fitting glove.

Stephen Billington plays the despicable cad Brad with the veneer of charm and the underbelly of pure evil. One wonders throughout the play just how long Kara (Charlotte Harwood) will put up with his misogyny. Russell Dixon portrays Alice’s (Elizabeth Boag) husband Derek with impeccable timing (just like his train!) and irresistible charm. The six actors in “Hero’s Welcome” deliver authentic and engaging performances. Less engaging is the script itself.

The script is convoluted and its characters underdeveloped. While Murray’s, Alice’s, and Kara’s conflicts are clear and their motivations believable, other characters lack authentic conflicts and their contribution to the forward movement of the plot often stalls the play’s overall progress. Why, for example, Kara’s daughter Simone (also played by Ms. Harwood) appears in the last scene to burn down The Bird of Prey is as puzzling as it is unnecessary. Despite having a contemporary setting and feel, “Hero’s Welcome” rehearses Mr. Ayckbourn’s important themes – “man’s inhumanity to woman” and the lack of transparency – with a less than contemporary feel. Still, “Hero’s Welcome” is an interesting story with redemptive themes and worth the visit.


The cast for “Hero’s Welcome” features Stephen Billington, Elizabeth Boag, Russell Dixon, Charlotte
Harwood, Evelyn Hoskins, and Richard Stacey. The design team for both plays is Jason Taylor (lighting designer) and Michael Holt (production designer). The production stage manager is Veronica Aglow. Production photos by Tony Bartholomew.

Alan Ayckbourn’s “Hero’s Welcome” and “Confusions” run in rep for their New York City premieres at Brits Off Broadway at 59E59 Theaters with a general performance schedule of Tuesday – Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; Sunday at 3:00 p.m. and 7:00p.m. Please see the performance calendar for the individual show schedules. Single tickets for “Hero’s Welcome” and “Confusions” are $70.00 ($49.00 for 59E59 Members). To purchase tickets, call Ticket Central at (212) 279-4200 or go to Running time for “Hero’s Welcome” is 2 hours and 25 minutes with one twenty-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, June 9, 2016

Review: “Confusions” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Sunday July 3, 2016)

L-R: Elizabeth Boag, Stephen Billington, and Russell Dixon in "Confusions," written and directed by Alan Ayckbourn, part of Brits Off Broadway at 59E59 Theaters. Photo by Tony Bartholomew.
Review: “Confusions” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Sunday July 3, 2016)
Written and Directed by Alan Ayckbourn
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Alan Ayckbourn is unquestionably a prolific and popular playwright whose seventy-nine plays have delighted and challenged audiences for almost sixty years. He has explored the vicissitudes of the human condition with pith and panache and often focuses on the relationships between women and men and, most often, on the misdeeds of the latter gender. The Stephen Joseph Theatre in Scarborough England has chosen to revive the playwright’s “Confusions” at 59E59 Theaters as part of the Brits Off Broadway Series.

A series of five interconnected plays, “Confusions” flips a character from the first play into the next play until the themes of the first four pieces collide on a park bench in “A Talk in the Park.”

In “Mother Figure,” Lucy (Elizabeth Boag) a frazzled young mother struggles to balance sanity with caring for her children without any assistance from her mostly absent gad-about husband. Her neighbor Rosemary, concerned she has not seen Lucy recently, makes a visit and experiences an abundance of uber-nurturing unlike the care she receives from her sexist hubby Terry (Stephen Billington). In the second play “Drinking Companion” Lucy’s absentee hubby Harry (Richard Stacey) is found trying to pick up two women in a hotel lounge. Terry is the ultimate sexist cad who does not manage to fool Paula (Charlotte Harwood) or her friend Bernice (Elizabeth Boag) but manages inadvertently to garner the attention of the gay waiter (Stephen Billington) who appears in the third play “Between Mouthfuls” the ultimate in cuckolding comedy. Mr. and Mrs. Pearce (Russell Dixon and Elizabeth Boag) dine unaware of Mr. Pearce’s employee Martin (Richard Stacey) who is in the same restaurant with his wife Polly (Charlotte Harwood) who has had a bit of a tryst with her hubby’s boss.

In the second act, Mrs. Pearce is the honored guest at “Gosforth’s Fete” a celebration of all that can possibly go wrong at a civic event. Gosforth (Russell Dixon) has managed to have a tryst with Stewart’s (Stephen Billington) fiancé Milly (Charlotte Harwood). The Vicar (Richard Stacey) serves as the moral trope amidst the amoral mayhem. At the performance I attended, the audience went wild over this piece guffawing loudly accompanied by knee-slapping and double-overs. This critic was quite frankly quite bored.

What was undoubtedly unique in 1974 – and what most audiences still find hilarious on both sides of the Pond - I find sad for some reason. It all seems just too dated and irrelevant. Watching “Confusions” is akin to watching a piece of history while laughing at important issues we have yet to resolve. And while it is therapeutic to laugh at ourselves and our foibles, there needs to be some other payoff to two hours and fifteen minutes of tom foolery.

Under Mr. Ayckbourn’s direction, the ensemble cast is brilliant and does its individual and collective best to breathe new life into these five plays. It is the vintage of the plays and not the craft of these fine actors that weigh down the effort. Michael Holt’s design and Jason Taylor’s lighting are appropriate and complement the action of each play with style.

Sexism, adultery, and abuse – these three remain today in abundance - but reviving a 1970’s look at these horrific and persistent problems does little to massage the conscience or quicken the spirit of compassion. Mr. Ayckbourn’s impressive body of work is to be celebrated but not worshipped and something beyond “Confusions” is needed to sort out the sexual turbulence of the twenty-first century.

“Confusions” plays in repertory with Mr. Ayckbourn’s new play “Hero’s Welcome” through July 3, 2016.


The cast for “Confusions” features Stephen Billington, Elizabeth Boag, Russell Dixon, Charlotte
Harwood, and Richard Stacey. The design team for both plays is Jason Taylor (lighting designer) and Michael Holt (production designer). The production stage manager is Veronica Aglow. Production photos by Tony Bartholomew.

Alan Ayckbourn’s “Hero’s Welcome” and “Confusions” run in rep for their New York City premieres at Brits Off Broadway at 59E59 Theaters with a general performance schedule of Tuesday – Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; Sunday at 3:00 p.m. and 7:00p.m. Please see the performance calendar for the individual show schedules. Single tickets for “Hero’s Welcome” and “Confusions” are $70.00 ($49.00 for 59E59 Members). To purchase tickets, call Ticket Central at (212) 279-4200 or go to Running time for “Confusions” is 2 hours and 15 minutes with one twenty-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, June 9, 2016

Review: The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois at the Atlantic Theater Company Stage 2 (Through Sunday June 19, 2016)

(L-R) William Apps, Katherine Reis and Susan Heyward in "The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois." Photo by Ahron Foster
Review: The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois at the Atlantic Theater Company Stage 2 (Through Sunday June 19, 2016)
Written and Directed by Adam Rapp
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“I like your sweater. That color’s good on you. Is that purple? (Ellis to his daughter) “So sometimes when I close my eyes there are cats and ocelots and burning trees. And sometimes the trees run like men on fire and sometimes there are ocelots up in the branches and they’re burning too.” (Ellis in “The Purple Lights of Joppa”)

Social media plays a significant role in “Adam Rapp’s “The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois” currently playing at Atlantic Stage 2. Ellis (William Apps) a father in Paducah Kentucky sends a Friend request to his estranged daughter Catherine (Katherine Reis) in Joppa Illinois and she accepts his invitation and they begin to chat. Seems simple enough – another example of reconnecting with family through Facebook. However, this connection is complicated. Ellis contacts his daughter through his nurse Barrett’s (Connor Barrett) Facebook account and father and daughter agree to meet at Ellis’s small street-level duplex apartment in Paducah at a specific time during Barrett’s next home visit to Ellis.

Adding to the fragility – and the excitement - of this bumpy ride, Catherine’s mother thinks Catherine is taking a walk around the block back in Joppa with her friend Monique (Susan Heyward); however, Monique – using the driver’s license of her thirty-seven-year-old aunt Takayda Flowers - makes the trip to Paducah with Catherine and is packing – of all things – her Uncle Levon’s Taser gun. This is but a portion of the exposition for Mr. Rapp’s play about a mentally ill father and a love-starved daughter that have no choice but to embrace change in the midst of chaos.

For five minutes during their visit, Ellis and Catherine stare at each other and experience profound confession, forgiveness, and the beginning of reconciliation as they listen to Mickey Newbury’s “I Don’t Think Much About Her No More.” This is a brave choice for Mr. Rapp and for the cast and a choice that pays off with abundant rewards. When Ellis decides to play track number three from Newbury’s 1969 album “Looks Like Rain,” Ellis determines to leave his world of “boiling doors” and lights that move and risk reuniting with the daughter he left years before.

Much goes on in “The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois; however, to share too much of the action would spoil the overall experience of seeing this remarkable play. It is perhaps enough to say that there is intrigue, surprise, shock, confusion, and a redemptive vision of unconditional and nonjudgmental love. The audience needs to engage in every delicate moment of how Mr. Rapp’s extraordinary characters embrace their engaging conflicts to spin a tale of healing and release.

William Apps captures the depths of Ellis’s despair and the intensity of his bi-polar affective disorder, with psychosis with impeccable precision. Mr. Apps does not waste one movement, one gesture, one glance in his portrayal of Ellis and his monologue describing Ellis’s experience with his disorder is life-changing and emotionally exhausting. Katherine Reis captures Catherine’s innate inquisitiveness and her need to know why her father left her. In their scenes together, Mr. Apps and Ms. Reis are not merely emotionally connected: they are somehow physically entwined in a ballet of belief in change.

Susan Heyward delivers a believable Monique who is at once Catherine’s soulmate and her protector and her alter ego. And Connor Barrett balances his caring professional persona with his utter fear that he might lose his position were his “secret” to be revealed. This is a brilliant ensemble cast that exercises its collective and individual craft without reserve or trepidation.

Adam Rapp’s direction is remarkable and brims with intensity and subtlety. When – at some almost indiscernible place – Catherine (and even Monique) decide to forgive Ellis, understand Ellis, and embrace his massive soul, Mr. Rapp choreographs forgiveness in ways that are as deeply emotional as they are purely startling. Think costume designer Jessica Pabst forgot to remove the size label from Ellis’s new pants? Just sit back and wait!

Watching Ellis and Catherine choose to travel the often unchartered paths of forgiveness and reconciliation is deeply cathartic. They both know they have done “bad stuff.” However, Catherine’s lists and Ellis’s journeys to the outer fringes of madness and back have somehow saved them, offered them salvation at least. And it is from that well of human grappling that Adam Rapp – once again – baptizes us with hope.


“The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois” features William Apps, Connor Barrett, Susan Heyward, and Katherine Reis.

“The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois” features scenic design by Andromache Chalfant, costume design by Jessica Pabst, lighting design by Keith Parham, sound design by Christian Frederickson and casting by Carparelliotis Casting. Production photos by Ahron Foster.

“The Purple Lights of Joppa Illinois” runs at Atlantic Stage 2, 330 West 16th Street (between 8th and 9th Avenues), on the following schedule: Tuesday - Saturday at 7:30 p.m., Saturday and Sunday at 2:30 p.m. Tickets are available online at, by calling OvationTix at 866-811-4111, or in person at The Linda Gross Theater box office (336 West 20 Street between 8 & 9 Avenues). For information on Atlantic Theater Company membership or other inquiries, contact the Membership Department: 212-645-1242 or Running time is 90 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, June 7, 2016

Review: “Himself and Nora” at the Minetta Lane Theatre (Through Sunday September 4, 2016)

Photo: Himself and Nora by Jonathan Brielle, Directed by Michael Bush. From left to right: Matt Bogart & Whitney Bashor. Minetta Lane Theatre, 18 Minetta Lane, NYC. Photo by Matt Murphy.
Review: “Himself and Nora” at the Minetta Lane Theatre (Through Sunday September 4, 2016)
Book, Music, and Lyrics by Jonathan Brielle
Directed by Michael Bush
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“Himself and Nora,” currently playing at the Minetta Lane Theatre, follows the life and career of the iconic James Joyce (played with a stolid cheerfulness by Matt Bogart) and his muse Nora Barnacle (played with a steely charm by Whitney Bashor) with historical accuracy. Jonathan Brielle’s new musical highlights events in the couple’s lives in chronological order from their meeting and courting, their self-imposed exile to Europe, Joyce’s deteriorating eyesight, the difficulties in publishing “Ulysses” in America, the death of Joyce’s father and his daughter’s schizophrenia, and through to Joyce’s illness that resulted in his death. However, the musical is more than a timeline of life events of the famous couple.

Equally intriguing is the musical’s attention to issues that are known to have driven Joyce’s creative engine, including his love-hate (mostly hate) relationship with the Roman Catholic Church. Jonathan Brielle cleverly uses the omnipresent (and apparently omniscient) Priest (played with an appropriate snobbish priggishness by Zachary Prince) who is not only present on stage but, like an annoying Greek Chorus, comments on the action of the musical with acerbic pretense.

“Himself and Nora” is a delight for the senses particularly the sense of hearing. Matt Bogart has an engaging voice that soars through the register with delightful ease and impressive strength. Whitney Bashor’s vocal control is equally impressive. At times, her singing is so effortless, one might assume she is simply channeling the music! Mr. Bogart transfixes the audience with his “Land of Erin” and “Always in Love.” Ms. Bashor captures the heart and soul of the audience with “Stand Fast,” “Without A Man,” and “What Better Thing.” Additionally, both leads are superb actors who bring a high degree of authenticity to their multi-layered and complicated characters.

Under Michael Bush’s attentive and perceptive direction (these are not one and the same), the remaining supportive cast - Michael McCormick as Joyce’s Da and Ezra Pound and Lianne Marie Dobbs playing multiple roles including Joyce’s Mother – deliver impressive performances and exhibit strong vocal skills. Ms. Dobbs’ portrayal of Joyce’s mother is heartwarming and thoughtful.

Paul Tate dePoo III’s set design is towering both in size and in emotional content. Within his design, scenes change with ease while the focus always remains on the action on the stage. Amy Clark’s costumes are appropriate throughout and historically accurate. Jason Lyons’ lighting and Keith Caggiano’s sound complement and heighten the overall effective staging of the musical.

Although it seems at times “Himself and Nora” has not decided exactly what it wants to be, the overall effect of the new musical is pleasing and thoroughly captivating. It would seem the audience would wish to learn more of Joyce’s motivations throughout his life and a deeper understanding of his important relationships with his parents and siblings. “Himself and Nora” is not without some complications.

For example, although history confirms that the relationship between Joyce and Barnacle, especially prior to their late marriage, was highly sexually charged, “Himself and Nora” chooses to remind the audience of that fact in almost every scene of the new musical. There is more on stage groping, poking, and smelling than necessary. The story of Joyce and Nora clearly is more about Nora’s profound influence on Joyce’s ability to write about what he knew best: the people and the place of Ireland.

What “Himself and Nora” does accomplish, it achieves successfully and with considerable charm and is unquestionably worth a visit to the Minetta Lane Theatre. The new musical shares the life of a writer with an enormous ego (hence the title) who – though he struggles with a myriad of demons from without and within – remains one of the most important figures in the canon of modern literature.


The cast of “Himself and Nora” features Matt Bogart as James Joyce opposite Whitney Bashor as Nora, Lianne Marie Dobbs, Victoria Huston-Elem, Michael McCormick, Zachary Prince, and Gary Troy.

“Himself and Nora” has choreography by Kelli Barclay, set design by Paul Tate dePoo III, costume design by Amy Clark, lighting design by Jason Lyons, and sound design by Keith Caggiano. Casting is by Geoff Josselson, general management by DR Theatrical Management, production management by Production Core and production stage management by CJ LaRoche. Production photos by Matt Murphy.

Performances for “Himself and Nora” are Tuesdays at 7:00 p.m., Wednesdays at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m., Thursdays at 8:00 p.m., Fridays at 8:00 p.m., Saturdays at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m., and Sundays at 3:00 p.m. Tickets are $89.00 with premium and gold seating available. Tickets can be purchased by visiting,, or calling (800) 745-3000. Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes with one intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, June 7, 2016

Review: “Half Moon Bay” at Cherry Lane Theatre (Through Saturday June 4, 2016)

Photo: Keilly McQuail and Gabriel King. Credit: Steven Pisano.
Review: “Half Moon Bay” at Cherry Lane Theatre (Through Saturday June 4, 2016)
By Dan Moyer
Directed by Jess Chayes
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Okay. A Millennial young woman named Annie (Keilly McQuail) sits in a bowling alley bar late at night hunched over her beer as a second Millennial – a young man named Gabe (Gabriel King) – enters the bar from the lanes. Annie says, “Nice shoes.” Gabe responds, “What?” So begins Dan Moyer’s new play “Half Moon Bay” currently running at the Cherry Lane Studio Theatre and presented by Cherry Lane’s inaugural Company in Residence Lesser America. And so, too, begins the story of the Frankie-and-Johnny-like pair as they attempt to find grounding in a relationship seemingly doomed from the start.

Decidedly under the influence, Gabe and Annie embark on a cat-and-mouse adventure that leads to a second meeting at the bar and the not-so-surprising tryst at Annie’s apartment where additional beer, vodka (once with Vitamin Water), and cocaine fuel a truth-or-dare extravaganza that reveals a plethora of dysfunctional fallout not ameliorated by night and day time views of Half Moon Bay. This is a troubled couple who face every moment as if it were their last, laughing at their foibles yet cowering in fear in the corners of their deepest secrets.

Under Jess Chayes’ meticulous and spirited direction, Keilly McQuail and Gabriel King are the kingpins in this Lesser America production. Their emotional honesty is sometimes too much to bear, and their unwavering commitment to Mr. Moyer’s script is evident in every moment of every scene of the two-act play. Ms. McQuail brings a steely vulnerability to her Annie Barlev that perfectly counterpoints the droopy determination Mr. King brings to his Gabe Hester. They peel away the complex layers of their rich characters with care and bravery and leave nothing of the underbelly of their lives buried. In those places where Mr. Moyer’s script falters, these two actors fill in the gaps with the grit of their formidable craft.

Kudos to the run crew (Zachary Cohn, Maddi Knox, and Alexandra Scordato) who change Reid Thompson’s stark bowling alley bar into Annie’s messy apartment in a matter of minutes. Watching the changeover is akin to celebrating the completion of a complex jigsaw puzzle. M. Meriwether Snipes’ costumes, Mike Inwood’s bright to brooding lighting, and Janie Bullard’s sound design create the perfect border to this spot on design of perfectly matched interlocking pieces.

Annie and Gabe reveal the guts of a generation caught between forebears of success and failure, seeking sure footing in a landscape littered with doubt and despair, yearning for independence yet ensnared in webs of family systems often gone haywire. Not all have quite the level of depressive ennui as Gabe and Annie – though many do – but these two Millennial seekers serve as a powerful trope of a generation upon which depends the future of a nation and a global community. Enamored by credit card debt and numbed by a culture of sedation, this generation teeters on the edge of a precipice created by the collapse of two towers.

For better or for worse, playwright Dan Moyer decides to wrap up his new play with some sugarcoated surcease of despair. Whether that rings true is a matter of opinion. Perhaps the play would have been more cohesive had Gabriel walked out of Annie’s apartment without cab money and sporting plastic bag shoes instead of the expensive Etonics he lost in a bet or if Annie remained alone in her apartment leaving the audience to wonder if she will go down the stairs to meet her mother or open yet another can of beer or snort another line of cocaine. But perhaps that is just too much despair for the audience to bear in a year of political madness and unrelenting violence.

However, as it stands, “Half Moon Bay” is a testament to the strength of the human spirit and the unrelenting hope of finding salvation in the face of the other.


The cast of “Half Moon Bay” features Keilly McQuail and Gabriel King.

“Half Moon Bay” features set design by Reid Thompson, costume design by M. Meriwether Snipes, lighting design by Mike Inwood, and sound design by Janie Bullard. Production photos by Steven Pisano.

“Half Moon Bay” runs through Saturday June 4, Friday – Sunday at 8:00 p.m. at the Cherry Lane Theatre, 38 Commerce Street (three blocks south of Christopher Street, just west of Seventh Avenue – accessible from 1 train to Christopher Street). Tickets are $18.00, available at 212-352-3101 or Running time is just under 2 hours.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, June 3, 2016

Review: “Cal in Camo” at Rattlestick Playwrights Theater (Through Sunday June 12, 2016)

Photo: Katya Campbell and Paul Wesley. Credit: Carol Rosegg.
Review: “Cal in Camo” at Rattlestick Playwrights Theater (Through Sunday June 12, 2016)
By William Francis Hoffman
Directed by Adrienne Campbell-Holt
Reviewed by David Roberts

Cal (played with a haunting despair by Katya Campbell) is in a mess. Urban Chicago was the ideal place for her husband Tim (played with a brave vulnerability by David Harbour) to make money pitching beer distributors’ craft brews but not the ideal place for Cal – who grew up in rural Missouri – to live and the raise her new baby. So she moves her family to rural Illinois, agreeing to purchase the last lot remaining in the development that has remained unsold because it is adjacent to a sinkhole. Cal’s mess does not end with her bad real estate decision. She is clinically depressed and suffering from a depersonalization/derealization disorder and a borderline family estrangement disorder. If all of that were not enough, Cal has dipped into the family’s paltry coffers to fly her brother Flynt (played with a passive but resilient sweetness by Paul Wesley) home after the sudden and tragic death of his wife.

Flynt’s entry into his sister’s already fragile family system provides an interesting turning-point in William Francis Hoffman’s “Cal in Camo” currently playing at the Rattlestick Playwrights Theater in collaboration with the Brooklyn based Colt Coeur. We learn from Flynt the provenance of Cal’s inability to connect with herself or with others on any significant and deep level. Her disorders can be traced – at least partially – to a fractured relationship with her mother who walked out on Cal and only left this adult-child with the memory of her mother as a “nameless taste.” The world premiere of this new play follows the path of healing for Cal, her husband, her brother, and her child. This healing comes in stages after significant conversations between the members of the family – conversations that include an extended conversation between Flynt and Tim and Flynt’s lengthy monologue in his final conversation with Cal.

These conversations are enriched with figurative language, imagery, symbolism, and other tropes. Some of these tropes are more effective than others and they serve the script best when they are subtle or even elusive. Others – like the ever-present sinkhole (or is it a rabbit hole?) - are predictable and not as satisfying. A vintage rifle, a bullet that was rendering the rifle unusable, a doe (yes, a familiar lyric tumbles from Flynt’s lips), storms, power outages, and a fissure in the new house struggle to take on meaning in Mr. Hoffman’s script. Sometimes a direct and transparent bit of dialogue goes a long way to bring sense and sensibility to a script. One example would be the indication that Flynt has started his healing process just before he leaves Cal to catch a bus home to find his wife’s body in the river that swept her away. Flynt tells Cal, “I don’t need your motherin’ wanna be a mother mother your baby not me.”

Although the ensemble cast members deliver impressive performances with authenticity and believability, Mr. Hoffman’s script is somewhat less impressive as is Colt Coeur’s Adrienne Campbell-Holt’s direction. The script – though replete with dense text that easily engages the audience – is often less than believable and the character’s traits are not always consistent. And the rising action feels forced at times putting characters in situations solely to provide exposition and not to allow their conflicts to enrich the plot. Ms. Campbell-Holt’s direction is serviceable but rarely stretches beyond the basics. Both – script and direction sometimes border on the pretentious; however, “Cal in Camo” is at times an engaging psychological study of one fractured family system that has abundant connections to every member of the audience.

One looks forward to future collaborations between Rattlestick and Colt Coeur and to Rattlestick’s new season.


The cast of “Cal in Camo” features Katya Campbell, David Harbour, and Paul Wesley.

“Cal in Camo” features scenery by John McDermott, costumes by Sueann Leung, lighting
by Grant Yeager, sound design by Amy Altadonna, properties by Deb Gaouette, and production
management by Jeremy Pape. Sarah Devon Ford will serve as Production Stage Manager. Production photos by Carol Rosegg.

“Cal in Camo” plays Sundays and Mondays at 7:00 p.m., Wednesdays through Fridays at 8:00 p.m., and
Saturdays at 3:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m. Tickets start at $30.00 and may be purchased at,, or by calling Ovationtix at (866) 811-4111. Special artist and student discount rates are available. Running time is 80 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, May 31, 2016

Review: You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown” at the York Theatre Company (Through Sunday June 26, 2016)

The “Peanut” Gang (Left to Right): Mavis Simpson-Ernst as Lucy, Milly Shapiro as Sally, Joshua Colley as Charlie Brown, Jeremy T. Villas as Linus, Gregory Diaz as Schroeder, and Aiden Gemme as Snoopy. Photo credit: Carol Rosegg.
Review: You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown” at the York Theatre Company (Through Sunday June 26, 2016)
Book, Music and Lyrics by Clark Gesner and additional material by Andrew Lippa and Michael Mayer
Directed by Michael Unger
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

The new production of “You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown” at the York Theater Company would seem to be a clever idea, using age appropriate actors to portray the renowned Peanuts characters, especially after a successful concert version at “54 Below.” The difficulty with this concept is that the show was not written for children to perform. The vocals needed for many of the songs require mature voices with a wide range and adequate support to sustain the notes that are important to the humor and emotional content. The book is sophisticated and difficult for a child to comprehend, especially when dealing with the timing and the delivery needed to convey the message. What is so appealing about this show when performed by adults is that they become cartoon characters because they are not age appropriate but they have the knowledge, experience and vocal range to sustain the script. They may appear to be silly but actually are remarkably perceptive. It then has the ability to please children and adults on different levels.

This is not a question of whether the performances of the actors in this particular production are adequate rather than whether the casting was age appropriate for the material. At the matinee performance I attended there were many families or parents with children in the audience. The children - although well behaved - became restless midway through the first hour-long act. The characters they were watching were not animated, they were their peers. Adults seemed unresponsive to the intelligent and perceptive script mainly because, at times, the actors/characters had difficulty perceiving the humor in the intended meaning and this lack of perception affected the timing. It might have been an enjoyable afternoon but the show did not live up to its potential. Even when seeing these characters in a comic strip or television special they have the look of being little animated adults rather children. There is something magical about adults finding the child in them. There is something missing – the charm perhaps - when children find the adult in themselves.

The music is delightful with pianist Eric Svejcar at the helm as conductor assuring at all times that the music is the driving force. The scenic design by Brian Prather is adequate but the costumes by Grier Coleman could be a bit brighter and more imaginative. Perhaps after a few performances under their belt this talented group of young performers will become more confident as they bring the Peanuts gang to life on the stage.


Directed by York’s Associate Artistic Director Michael Unger, and with music direction by Eric Svejcar and choreography by Jennifer Paulson-Lee, the seven-member “Peanuts” cast features Joshua Colley as Charlie Brown, Gregory Diaz as Schroeder, Aidan Gemme as Snoopy, Milly Shapiro Sally, Mavis Simpson-Ernst as Lucy, and Jeremy T. Villas as Linus. Graydon Peter Yosowitz will perform the role of Charlie Brown from June 1-7.

The creative team for “You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown” includes Brian Prather (sets), Grier Coleman, (costumes), Graham Kindred (lights), and Daniel Logan (props). The Production Stage Manager is T.J. Kearney and the Assistant Stage Manager is Rachel Calter. Casting is by Nora Brennan Casting. Production Photos by Carol Rosegg.

“You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown” plays the following performance schedule: Tuesdays and Wednesdays at 7:00 p.m., Thursdays – Saturdays at 8:00 p.m., Saturdays and Sundays at 2:30 p.m.

Tickets for “You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown” are priced at $67.50 - $72.50 and may be purchased by calling (212) 935-5820, online at, or in person at the box office at the York Theatre at Saint Peter’s (Citicorp Building, entrance on East 54th Street, just east of Lexington Avenue), Tuesday through Friday (12:00 p.m. - 6:00 p.m.). York Theatre Members receive priority booking and save almost 35% on matinee performances and 30% for regular performances. Student and Senior Rush tickets are available in-person beginning one hour prior to performances for $20.00 cash only. The York Theatre also offers $25.00 tickets for guests aged 35 years and under.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, May 31, 2016

Review: “American Psycho” Teases the Psyche at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre (Open Run)

Photo: Benjamin Walker as Patrick Bateman. Credit: Jeremy Daniel
Review: “American Psycho” Teases the Psyche at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre (Open Run)
Book by Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa (Based on the Novel by Bret Easton Ellis)
Music and Lyrics by Duncan Sheik
Directed by Rupert Goold
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Change one letter in the phrase ‘American Psycho’ to form a phrase that describes the essence of Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa/Duncan Sheik’s musical currently playing at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre - a phrase that handily explains why the musical garnered such praise on the London stage. The result: ‘American Psyche.” Brits love watching the foibles of their “children across the pond” play out on the stage – especially antics that arise from the specific character of the American experience. Certainly the final year of the 1980s provides a plethora of deadly sins and detritus from the opening of Pandora’s box/jar. Think “Enron” on steroids.

Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa’s book brims with the excesses of 1989 America and these come into sharp focus in the character of the protagonist Patrick Bateman (Benjamin Walker) and the coterie of mindless and vapid individuals he surrounds himself with including his girlfriend Evelyn Williams (Helene Yorke); his best friend Timothy Price (Theo Stockman); and his co-workers Craig McDermott (Alex Michael Stoll), David Van Patten (Dave Thomas Brown), and Luis Carruthers (Jordan Dean).

Mergers and acquisitions analyst Patrick Bateman barely hangs on to reality and his coping mechanisms dwindle as his ego strength wanes. The “existential horror” that is America resonates with a similar horror that haunts his psyche resulting in a spate of “murders and executions” that appear to be more matters of fantasy than acts of reality. It is clear that what haunts the young, ripped, and handsome analyst is the same dystopian future facing the nation itself.

Were it not for Benjamin Walker’s formidable craft, “American Psycho” would be as much of a horror as Mr. Aguirre-Sacsa’s weak and shallow book – this musical is pure comic book and more anime than theatre. And Duncan Skeik’s music and lyrics are equally unsatisfactory. As syrupy as Patrick’s secretary Jean’s (Jennifer Damiano) love ballad “A Girl Before” is, under Ms. Damiano’s care, it far outshines the majority of the musical numbers.

Other exceptions are the numbers sung by Benjamin Walker who brings as much honesty to his character Patrick Bateman as possible. “Common Man,” “The End of an Island” (with Ms. Damiano), and “This Is Not an Exit” stand out in the list of some twenty-two musical numbers.

Like Hans Christian Andersen’s delusional Emperor, Patrick Bateman is depicted most of the time in some state of near-nudity. And although Benjamin Walker pulls that task off well, it does not fully justify the overuse of that trope that is meant to highlight the ignorance, incompetence, and boorishness of contemporary American society.

“American Psycho” is worth the visit to see Mr. Walker’s electrifying performance – suited up or strutting around in bloodied underwear in the second act’s extended “dream” sequence – and to allow his Patrick Bateman to rattle the recesses of the American psyche within and outside the theatre.


“American Psycho” has music direction by Jason Hart, and music supervision and vocal arrangements by David Shrubsole.

The cast of “American Psycho” features Krystina Alabado, Dave Thomas Brown, Jennifer Damiano, Jordan Dean, Anna Eilinsfeld, Jason Hite, Ericka Hunter, Holly James, Brandon Kalm, Drew Moerlein, Sydney Morton, Alice Ripley, Anthony Sagaria, Keith Randolph Smith, Theo Stockman, Alex Michael Stoll, Benjamin Walker, Morgan Weed, Helene Yorke, and Neka Zang.

“American Psycho has scenic design by Es Devlin, costume design by Katrina Lindsay lighting design by Justin Townsend, sound design by Dan Moses Schreier, and video design by Finn Ross Casting is by Telsey + Company/Craig Burns, CSA. Production photos by Jeremy Daniel.

The regular performance schedule for “American Psycho” is: Monday, Tuesday and Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; and Sunday at 2:00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m. Wednesdays are dark (please visit for variations to this schedule).

Tickets for “American Psycho” are priced $69.00 - $148.00 ($225.00 - $250.00 for premium seating) and are available via or by phone at (212) 239-6200. Running time is 2 hours and 30 minutes with a 15-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, May 26, 2016

Review: “Peer Gynt” at the Classic Stage Company (Through Sunday June 19, 2016)

Pictured - Becky Ann Baker and Gabriel Ebert. Photo by Joan Marcus.
Review: “Peer Gynt” at the Classic Stage Company (Through Sunday June 19, 2016)
By Henrik Ibsen
Directed and Adapted by John Doyle
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

"I tell you the truth, unless a kernel of wheat falls to the ground and dies, it remains only a single seed. But if it dies, it produces many seeds. The man who loves his life will lose it, while the man who hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life." (John 12:24)

One legitimate critical strategy for reading/viewing Henrik Ibsen’s epic verse play “Peer Gynt” is the mythological (sometimes referred to as the archetypal) strategy – the strategy that interprets the hopes, fears, and expectations of entire cultures. As directed and adapted by the Classic Stage Company’s John Doyle, Ibsen’s “Peer Gynt” is the story of the quest of a young man who willingly descends to the underworld and ascends to heaven in search of his “self.”

In the beginning of Ibsen’s 1867 play – written during his lengthy self-imposed exile in Italy – Peer’s (played with a self-effacing vulnerability by Gabriel Ebert) mother (played with a resilient hopefulness by Becky Ann Baker) claims he should be ashamed of himself. And throughout the play, Peer is confronted with making choices that affect his self-understanding and his need for self-effacement. Ibsen’s script is heavily seasoned with allusions to Judeo-Christian texts, particularly those from the New Testament that resonate with self-discovery, repentance, and salvation. Early on, the Undertaker expresses the need to “save [Peer’s] soul.”

It is only his encounters with Solveig (played with the wisdom of innocence by Quincy Tyler Bernstine) that give him clarity, challenge him to continue to search, and – ultimately – offer him solace on his journey from home back home. Like Penelope, Solveig is patient and forgiving: “But I know that you will come in the end, And I will wait, as I promised I would. God guard you - wherever you may be. God give you joy - if you stand before Him.” She also encourages Peer to be faithful and contrite.

Peer neither finds his ‘self’ at home (initially), nor at his father’s banquet, nor during his encounter with the trolls (a wonderful archetypal image). Near the end of the play, Peer meets the Undertaker (another wonderful archetypal image). Peer asks, “One question. What does it mean: “To be one’s self?” The Undertaker (played with a haunting persistence by Adam Heller) replies, “To be one’s self is to kill one self. But that explanation’s probably wasted on you. Let’s just say: to follow - in all ways - the Master’s intention.” This is pure and powerful mythos.

Though typically - with good reason – Peer is compared to Odysseus, Don Giovanni and Faust, a more fitting and certainly subtler comparison would be with T.S. Eliot’s J. Alfred Prufrock or Shakespeare’s “Seven Stages of Man” from “As You Like It.” Often Peer’s journey is much like J. Alfred Prufrock’s whose words resonate deeply with Peer’s: “I am no prophet — and here’s no great matter; I have seen the moment of my greatness flicker, And I have seen the eternal Footman hold my coat, and snicker, And in short, I was afraid.” Peer “fears being a dead man before he dies.”

Rounding out the engaging cast are Jane Pfitsch as the fetching Bride, Dylan Baker as the conniving Doctor, and George Abud as the soulful Bridegroom. David L. Arsenault’s minimal set design and Jane Cox’s simple monochromatic lighting work well with this fittingly sparse production directed with an eye to detail and connection by John Doyle.

When Peer returns home and asks, “Where was my self - my true self - the Peer who bore God’s
stamp on his brow,” Solveig replies “In my faith, in my hope - in my love.” Ibsen’s “Peer Gynt” restores the hope that these three things might abide and restore our wounded hearts and disillusioned selves.


The cast of “Peer Gynt” features Gabriel Ebert as Peer, George Abud, Becky Ann Baker, Dylan Baker, Quincy Tyler Bernstine, Adam Heller and Jane Pfitsch. Scenic design is by David L. Arsenault, costume design by Ann Hould-Ward, lighting design by Jane Cox, and original music and sound design by Dan Moses Schreier. Production photos by Joan Marcus.

“Peer Gynt” performs Tuesdays through Thursdays at 7:00 p.m.; Fridays and Saturdays at 8:00 p.m. and Sundays at 3:00 p.m. Tickets are $60.00 on weeknights and $65.00 on weekends and are available at or by calling (212) 352-3101 / 866-811-4111 or at the box-office at 136 East 13th Street, New York City (between Third and Fourth Avenues). Running time is 2 hours without intermission.

Pictured - Becky Ann Baker and Gabriel Ebert. Photo by Joan Marcus.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, May 25, 2016

Review: “Incognito” at Manhattan Theatre Club at New York City Center Stage I

Pictured (L to R): Morgan Spector, Geneva Carr, Heather Lind, and Charlie Cox. Credit: Joan Marcus.
Review: “Incognito” at Manhattan Theatre Club at New York City Center Stage I
By Nick Payne
Directed by Doug Hughes
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

The jury remains out in the scientific community: which came first the brain or the mind? Throw into the discussion precisely where memory resides and how it is accessed and the debate becomes even more interesting and convoluted. Playwright Nick Payne focuses his interest on the brain and memory and in the American premiere of his “Incognito” – currently playing at the Manhattan Theatre Club at New York City Center Stage I – he raises enduring questions that challenge the status quo assumptions about both.

How much of what we experience, remember, and think is real? Are our brains passive data banks that receive, store and render up the reality we experience or do our brains process what we experience, remember, and think with some sleight of hand? In other words, can our brains “trick” us and if they can, are there ways to harness that chicanery to enrich our lives and perhaps the lives of others?

The four actors in “Incognito” double up and portray twenty characters within three interwoven stories. All of the action takes place on, on the edge of, or just beyond Scott Pask’s stark “brainscape” set. There are only four chairs on the stage. The actors remain in the same costumes – designed by Catherine Zuber – throughout and speak a variety of dialects making it necessary for the audience to remain focused and diligent throughout. However, one needs to remember that what one is seeing is hurtling out from the “brain” and is, at best, illusory and unreliable. So whether one keeps track of all of the characters in the three stories all of the time might not be important.

The three stories intertwine in episodic – not chronological – fashion and involve three functions of the brain: encoding; storing; and retrieving. These functions comprise three “scenes” in which all three stories continue in random order and without regard to the passage of time. Prior to each “scene,” the four actors engage in a stylized and well-choreographed arm and hand movements mimicking the synaptic firing in the brain. These “dances” – directed by Peter Pucci - give the audience members an opportunity to re-boot their own brain for the action to come.

In one story, pathologist Thomas Harvey (Morgan Spector) steals Albert Einstein’s brain after performing the deceased icon’s autopsy. In another, neuropsychologist Martha Murphy (Geneva Carr) experiences her first romance with another woman Patricia Thorn (Heather Lind). And in the third story, a seizure patient Henry Maison (Charlie Cox) forgets everything but how much he loves his fiancé Margaret Thomson (Heather Lind). The stories blend into one another without warning and the dialogue is rapid and overlapping.

Each of the four actors also portrays characters that are part of these stories: Thomas’ wife Eloise (Geneva Carr); Einstein’s daughter (Geneva Carr); Martha’s brother Ben (Charlie Cox); and Henry’s physician Victor Milner (Morgan Spector). And this is only ten of the twenty characters in the play!

What happens to Einstein’s brain, Thomas Harvey’s marriage, Martha and Patricia’s romance, and Henry’s memory – including his ability to remember how to play the piano – makes up the engaging ninety minutes of Mr. Payne’s important play. Each actor gives their multiple characters distinct characteristics, mannerisms, and speech patterns. This results in authentic and believable performances throughout. Doug Hughes’ direction is necessarily fast-paced and exact demanding the actors fall into and out of character with lightning speed – not as fast as the crossing of a synapse in the brain, but fast.

Ben Stanton’s lighting and David Van Tieghem’s original music and sound design add to the suspense and the overall success of the production. Kudos as well to dialect coach Stephen Gabis and fight director J. David Brimmer.

As the audience tries to keep pace with the action on stage, their individual and collective brains are processing information, deciding how to store it, and just how to make it available for retrieval. Our brains are creating new pathways as we watch – a remarkable feat. And as we leave the theatre, we will ultimately have to decide whether what we experienced was real, fiction, or perhaps pure illusion. And we will discover whether Einstein was a genius because of his brain or because “Albie worked like a dog and he treated his family like crap.” Yes, it will be a bit of a glorious bumpy ride.


The cast of “Incognito” features Geneva Carr, Charlie Cox, Heather Lind, and Morgan Spector.

The creative team for “Incognito” features Scott Pask (scenic design), Catherine Zuber (costume design), Ben Stanton (lighting design), David Van Tieghem (original music & sound design), J. David Brimmer (fight director), Peter Pucci (movement direction), and Stephen Gabis (dialect coach). Production photos by Joan Marcus.

Single tickets for “Incognito” are available by calling CityTix at 212-581-1212, online by visiting, or by visiting New York City Center box office (131 West 55th Street). All tickets are $90. The running time is 90 minutes with no intermission.

Pictured (L to R): Morgan Spector, Geneva Carr, Heather Lind, and Charlie Cox. Credit: Joan Marcus.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, May 25, 2016

Review: “Hadestown” Redefines Mythos at the New York Theatre Workshop (Through July 3 2016)

Photo: Damon Daunno as Orpheus and Nabiyah Be as Eurydice in "Hadestown." Credit: Joan Marcus.
Review: “Hadestown” Redefines Mythos at the New York Theatre Workshop (Through July 3 2016)
Written by Anaïs Mitchell
Developed with and Directed by Rachel Chavkin
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

With some surprise – and a modicum of disbelief – I overheard the two Millennials settling in behind me at the performance of “Hadestown” I attended at the New York Theatre Workshop sharing that they “had no idea” what the show they were there to see was about. Is it possible to reach ones 20s and 30s and not know the Orpheus and Eurydice myth? As the lights came back up following the performance, my despair transformed to hope: this remarkable and rich retelling of that myth will assuredly ignite interest in the Orpheus-Eurydice story as compellingly as “Hamilton” has renewed interest in America’s first Secretary of the Treasury.

Anaïs Mitchell’s “Hadestown” is a faithful retelling of this epic myth with a deep connection to the present and the plight of the 99 percent. Orpheus’ journey to rescue Eurydice from Hades and death, Persephone’s intervention on their behalf, and the gripping journey of the pair to the very Gates of Hell has never been more clear or more compelling.

Developed with the New York Theatre Workshop and Rachel Chavkin after the 2010 release of Anaïs Mitchell’s album of the same name, “Hadestown” retells the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice while counterpointing the tale with the reality of current political-social economics and challenges. Orpheus sings, “What we have we have to share.” Hades, on the other hand prefers building walls to keep the have nots away from those who have. Sound familiar?

The wonderful Chris Sullivan portrays Charon’s sidekick Hermes the psychopomp who narrates “Hadestown” and ushers the dead – and those who wish to rescue the dead – into and on occasion out of Hades on the train that “comes a-rollin’ clicketly clack” (not across the River Styx on a boat). His enchanting vocals reverberate through Hermes’ “Road to Hell,” “All I’ve Ever Known,” Way Down Hadestown,” and “Wait for Me.” Nabiyah Be portrays the deceased Eurydice who lands in Hades leaving her husband Orpheus pining for her above. Ms. Be’s remarkable vocal instrument brings a chilling authenticity to Ms. Mitchell’s “Wedding Song,” “All I’ve Ever Known,” “Chant I and II,” “Gone, I’m Gone,” “Flowers,” “Promises,” and “Wait for Me.”

Patrick Page (Hades) and Amber Gray (Persephone) handily bring the King and Queen of Hadestown to electrifying heights with remarkable performances and stunning vocals. Mr. Page’s range is astonishing and his low notes must be heard to be believed. Ms. Gray has a brilliant upper range that rings with the well-controlled interpretations of her songs. Standing out are their duets “Chant I” and “How Long;” Hades’ “Hey, Little Songbird,” “Why Build the Wall,” “Chant II,” and “His Kiss the Riot;” and Persephone’s “Livin’ It Up on Top,” “Way Down Hadestown,” “Chant I and II,” Our Lady of the Underground” (Entr’acte), “How Long,” and “I Raise My Cup to Him.”

The Fates Lulu Fall, Jessie Shelton, and Shaina Taub serve as a Greek Chorus as well as a stealthy superego. They weave through the action sometimes with a stark intrusion, sometimes with a gentle nudge. Their voices blend beautifully in their songs: “Any Way the Wind Blows,” When the Chips Are Down,” “Way Down Hadestown II,” Nothing Changes,” “Word to the Wise,” and the suspenseful “Doubt Comes In.”

Only the charming Damon Daunno seems to struggle with his role. His important Orpheus seems unable to match the richness and depth of the other performances. Perhaps it was the performance this critic attended but his voice seems surprisingly unsteady and occasionally pitchy. He reaches hard to be a fitting interloper in Hades and is sincere in his performance. His strong musical numbers include “Wedding Song” (with Ms. Be), “Epic I,” and “Wait for Me.”

Rachel Hauck’s set design, along with Bradley King’s lighting and Robert Kaplowitz’ sound, transform the New York Theatre Workshop’s space into a haunting Hades that beckons to the faint of heart and the weak of spirit. Ms. Mitchell’s scintillating “Hadestown” quickens the deadliness of our current political maelstrom and the social ennui it so weakly attempts to address. Like humankind’s attempts to “get it right,” “Hadestown” is “the tale of a love that never dies.” “It’s a sad song/It’s a sad tale, it’s a tragedy/It’s a sad song/But we sing it anyway” croons Hermes. One wonders how many more times we will “lift our cup” to Orpheus before we “see the world the way it could be in spite of the way it is.”


The cast of “Hadestown” features Nabiyah Be as Eurydice, Damon Daunno Orpheus, Lulu Fallas a Fate, Amber Gray as Persephone, Patrick Page as Hades, Jessie Shelton as a Fate, Chris Sullivan as Hermes, and Shaina Taub as a Fate.

The production features scenery by Rachel Hauck; costumes by Michael Krass; lighting by Jennifer Tipton; sound by Rob Kaplowitz; properites by Noah Mease; choreography by David Neumann; dramaturgy by Ken Cerniglia; music direction by Liam Robinson; arrangements and orchestrations by Michael Chorney; and co-arrangements and orchestrations and music supervision by Todd Sickafoose. “Hadestown” is co-conceived by Ben t. Matchstick. Production photos by Joan Marcus.

For more information on “Hadestown,” including performance schedule and ticketing, please visit Running time is 2 hours and 5 minutes including a 15-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, May 23, 2016

Review: “Indecent” at the Vineyard Theatre (Extended through Sunday June 19, 2016)

Photo: Adina Verson and Katrina Lenk. Credit: Carol Rosegg
Review: “Indecent” at the Vineyard Theatre (Extended through Sunday June 19, 2016)
Written by Paula Vogel
Created by Paula Vogel and Rebecca Taichman
Directed by Rebecca Taichman
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Created by Paula Vogel and Rebecca Taichman, “Indecent” could not have opened at the Vineyard Theatre at a more auspicious time. In the midst of an increasingly frenzied discussion about what is and what is not decent in contemporary American society and culture, this remarkable and stunning play - based on true events surrounding the 1923 Broadway debut of Sholem Asch’s “The God of Vengeance” - brings into sharp focus the importance of vigilance in the midst of intolerance and indomitability in the face of insidious censorship.

Portraying Sholem Asch, Max Gordon Moore delivers a riveting performance of a playwright who initially inspires his cast and crew as they begin to present “The God of Vengeance” but ultimately abandons them. Paula Vogel and Rebecca Taichman have created a compelling story about the power of innovation and the equally powerful effect of detachment and disinheriting oneself from the innovative process. The cast portrays the characters in three stages of their lives from the excitement of actors beginning a journey together in 1906 to their disappointments and fears that present themselves as they age and face the danger of the threat of the Nazi regime and beyond.

Mr. Moore and the other members of the stellar ensemble cast are listed as “Actors” in the program, he and all individuals – on or off stage – who take significant risks to maintain personal and professional integrity. Solem Asch’s failure to testify in court in Manhattan is a trope for the epic failure of all who shy from controversy and compromise rectitude for the assumed comfort of safety. Adina Verson and Katrina Lenk are riveting as Rifkele and Manke dance their way through life, death, and beyond death.

Rebecca Taichman directs “Indecent” with a sensitive precision. David Dorfman’s choreography is fluid with stunning lines and fresh contemporary movement. Emily Rebholz’s “dust to dust” costumes are intriguing and perfectly matched to the period. Both Christoper Akerlind’s lighting and Matt Hubbs’ sound are exquisite and create emotion-laden “pictures” that are as stunning as they are life-changing. With the assistance of “Stage Manager” Lemml (played with a self-effacing charm by Richard Topol), Tal Yarden’s projections guide the audience through language shifts, and shifts in time with ease.

Music and performances by Lisa Gutkin and Aaron Halva provide an essential emotional thread to “Indecent’s” important story.

It is difficult to rehearse here the entirety of the plot of “Indecent” driven by characters that share unimaginable conflicts that play out in a variety of settings without posting “spoiler alerts” in every paragraph. “Indecent” is a compelling piece of theatre that raises deep, enduring questions about the future of a society that refuses to accept differences and embrace those deemed to be “different.”


The cast of “Indecent” includes Katrina Lenk, Mimi Lieber, Max Gordon Moore, Tom Nelis, Steven Rattazzi, Richard Topol and Adina Verson.

“Indecent” features music composed and performed by Lisa Gutkin and Aaron Halva and choreography by David Dorfman. “Indecent” features set design by Riccardo Hernandez, costume design by Emily Rebholz, lighting design by Christopher Akerlind, sound design by Matt Hubbs, projection design Tal Yarden, fight choreography by Rick Sordelet and dialect coaching by Stephen Gabis. Casting is by Tara Rubin Casting. Production photos by Carol Rosegg.

Performances of “Indecent” have been extended through Sunday June 19, 2016 at the Vineyard Theatre, 108 East 15th Street. For more information, please call the box office at (212) 353-0303 or visit Running time is 1 hour and 40 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, May 23, 2016

Review: “Waitress” Satisfies the Senses at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre

Photo: Jessie Mueller (Jenna) in "Waitress." Credit: Joan Marcus.
Review: “Waitress” Satisfies the Senses at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre
Book by Jessie Nelson
Music and Lyrics by Sara Bareilles (Based on the Motion Picture Written by Adrienne Shelly)
Directed by Diane Paulus
Reviewed by Michele Willens
Theatre Reviews Limited

You will be forgiven if you walk into the Brooks Atkinson Theatre and wonder if you have mistakenly ended up at the neighborhood diner. Yes, that is the aroma of warm cinnamon tickling your nose. And yes, it turns out to be a pretty apt metaphor for the show you are about to see. “Waitress,” after all, mostly takes place inside a small town eatery, where the main character not only serves customers, but also bakes daily concoctions with names like Blueberry Bacon, Get Out of the Mud Pie, and Pursuit of Happiness.

Not that the musical, with book by Jessie Nelson and music by Sara Bareilles, is necessarily your grandma’s apple pie. This one has just enough spice to make it feel simultaneously nostalgic and contemporary. There is, after all, an abusive husband, an unwanted pregnancy, multiple affairs, and an ultimate sense of female empowerment.

Let’s start with the women thing, as even the story behind the story matters. “Waitress” was originally a lovely indie film starring Keri Russell. It was written and directed by Adrienne Shelly, who was tragically murdered shortly before the movie was released in 2007. This adaptation has been years in the making, (Notice I did not say “baking”) though it really got going when Jessie Mueller left her Tony-winning role as Carole King to take on the lead here. That was seen by some as a risky move - how many movies have been successfully transferred to stage musicals, after all? (“Hairspray” comes to mind, but then?)

It turned out that Mueller’s instincts are as sharp as her talent. This one has been selling tickets from previews to opening and beyond, and Mueller has once again been nominated for the Tony. She won’t win this time, but she delivers an endearing and accomplished performance.

She is Jenna, a pie-making waitress unhappily married to the dangerous Earl, a thankless part bravely portrayed by Nick Cordero. The more memorable characters are Jenna’s co-workers, Dawn and Becky, played, respectively by Kimiko Glenn and Keala Settle. The actresses are funny and touching in what could easily have been cartoon types.

The love interest is the new doctor in town, who supervises Jenna’s pregnancy and falls immediately in lust. He is charmingly/goofily played by Drew Gehling. There is chemistry and physicality here that manages to be both frisky and humorous. (Who knew “it’s deep-dish non-stick” could sound sexy?) Their first encounter spurs the witty song “A Pretty Good Bad Idea.”

The show is in female hands: direction by Diane Paulus, choreography by Lorin Latarro, the spoken words by screenwriter Jessie Nelson, and music and lyrics by five-time Grammy nominated singer and songwriter Sara Bareilles. This is primarily a pop score, not the usual sounds of Broadway, which makes it a perfect fit for Mueller, coming out of the tapestry of Carole King. The songs are generally lovely and fitting, and I have to say my favorite is “Take It from An Old Man,” sung by the lovably-curmudgeonly owner of the diner.

As for the drama of the show, there isn’t much. We wait to see if Jenna will give birth, if she and the good doctor will leave their spouses and run off together, if Jenna will enter and win a pie making contest, and so on. This is not a challenging night at the theatre but neither does it match the sugary stuff filling Jenna’s goodies. The audiences are, pardon the expression, eating it up. As you are encouraged to do, by the way, with a nightly choice of three freshly made tarts. I went with the Key Lime and felt perfectly satisfied. Which is pretty much how you are likely to feel after seeing “Waitress.”


“Waitress” is a presentation by Barry and Fran Weissler, and Norton and Elayne Herrick, with David I. Berley, Independent Presenters Network, A.C. Orange International, Peter May, Michael Roiff, Ken Schur, Marisa Sechrest, Jam Theatricals, 42nd club / Square 1 Theaters, Benjamin Simpson and Joseph Longthorne / Shira Friedman, and the American Repertory Theater.

“Waitress” is directed by Diane Paulus. Choreographed by Lorin Latarro. Sets, Scott Pask; costumes, Suttirat Anne Larlarb; lighting, Christopher Akerlind; sound, Jonathan Deans; wigs & makeup, Rachel Padula Shufelt & Jason Allen; orchestrations, Sara Bareilles & the Waitress Band; music supervision & arrangements, Nadia DiGiallonardo; production stage manager, Thomas J. Gates. Production photos by Joan Marcus.

With: Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn, Drew Gehling, NiickCordero, Dakin Matthews, Eric Anderson, and Christopher Fitzgerald.

For more information, including performance times and ticketing, please visit Running time 2 hours and 35 minutes.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Saturday, May 21, 2016

Review: “The Place We Built” at the Flea Theater (Through Monday May 30, 2016

Photo: Cast of "The Place We Built" Credit: Hunter Canninng
Review: “The Place We Built” at the Flea Theater (Through Monday May 30, 2016)
Written by Sarah Gancher
Directed by Danya Taymor
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“I like being able to define my species. And so I guess for the Seagull I don’t know anything, I’m an outside observer, but I think They found the beauty in being outside They made a place where they could define themselves.” Aisha/Nar

The thirty-something Jewish Bohemians in “The Place We Built,” currently running at the Flea Theater, who in 2001 established the Seagull (based on the true story of the Siraly) as a safe haven in Budapest gather in 2013 to decide whether they will – as ordered by the police – vacate their safe house or take a stand and hold up in the Seagull. Maria (Sonia Mena) announces to those assembled they have only 38 hours to make their decision – the decision that will change their lives forever. Do they take a stand or move on? These are the enduring and essential questions raised by Sarah Gancher in the world premiere of her high-energy, politically relevant play.

Ms. Gancher uses interviews (characters interviewing others and themselves) and flashbacks to establish exposition and to develop her characters. While these conventions clearly establish the political history of Budapest and the significant struggle of Jewish citizens to secure safety and acceptance, neither the interviews nor the multitude of flashbacks successfully develop the play’s characters as they define themselves in 2001 or in 2013 when the Seagull is shuttered “until further notice, maybe permanently.” Unfortunately, the firebrand Zoltan (Ash McNair) and his band of protestors remain shallow and flat making it difficult to care for them or for the important decisions they have to make.

The cast of “The Place We Built” is uniformly competent and compelling. Danya Taymor’s direction is uneven and often leaves the cast swarming across the stage to a form a mosh pit. Arnulfo Maldonado’s set is cleverly squeezed into the Flea’s small playing space and works quite well although part of the set requires a third of the audience to twist around if it wants to see the action or face forward and listen in only.

The strength of “The Place We Built” lies in its theme of resistance and transformation. Zoltan’s description of the zeal of the young people who gather at the closing and dismantling of the Seagull is chilling and haunting. Near the end of the play, Julia (Cleo Gray) confesses to Zoltan, “And I know the world is complicated. Everything is s**t. I don’t care. We have to keep trying. Things can change. I am changing.”

It is this youthful penchant for chasing hope that makes “The Place We Built” engaging and relevant and worth the visit.


“The Place We Built” features The Bats: Brittany K. Allen, Lydian Blossom, Tom Costello, Brendan Dalton, Tamara Del Rosso, Philip Feldman, Kristin Friedlander, Cleo Gray, Rachel Ingram, Ben Lorenz, Ash McNair, Sonia Mena, Isabelle Pierre, Xavier Reminick, Leta Renée-Alan, and Tessa Hope Slovis.

The creative team includes Arnulfo Maldonado (scenic design), Masha Tsimring (lighting design), Claudia Brown (costume design), Ben Truppin-Brown (sound design), Alex J. Gould (fight choreography), Zach Serafin (props master), Jocelyn Clarke (dramaturg), Charise Greene (dialect coach), Jake Beckhard (assistant director), and Tzipora Reman (stage management). Music direction and arrangements by The Bengsons. Production photos by Hunter Canning.

Performances run April 14 - May 30 at The Flea (41 White Street between Church and Broadway, three blocks south of Canal in Tribeca). For more information, including performance times and ticket process, please visit Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes plus intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Thursday, May 19, 2016

Preview: The New Group Announces 2016-2017 Season

Preview: The New Group Announces 2016-2017 Season
Preview by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

The New Group has announced four productions for its 2016-2017 Season. The company’s new season begins in Fall 2016 with the musical “Sweet Charity,” with choreography by Joshua Bergasse, directed by Leigh Silverman and featuring two-time Tony Award winner Sutton Foster in the title role. The New Group’s season continues in January 2017 with the U.S. premiere of Wallace Shawn’s “Evening at the Talk House,” directed by Scott Elliott; followed by the world premiere of “All the Fine Boys,” a new play from writer and director Erica Schmidt. In Spring 2017, The New Group presents the world premiere of “The Whirligig,” by Hamish Linklater, directed by Scott Elliott, featuring Zosia Mamet and Golden Globe winner Maura Tierney.

Productions in The New Group’s 2016-2017 Season take place at The Pershing Square Signature Center, 480 West 42nd Street.

Subscriptions and memberships for The New Group’s 2016-2017 season are available now. For subscription purchases and season info, please visit Subscriptions can also be purchased by calling Ticket Central at (212) 279-4200, or in person at 416 West 42nd Street (12-8pm daily).

Fall 2016:
“Sweet Charity.” Book by Neil Simon; Music by Cy Coleman; Lyrics by Dorothy Fields. Choreography by Joshua Bergasse. Directed by Leigh Silverman. Featuring Sutton Foster in the title role. Additional casting to be announced. Previews begin November 2016 in The Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre (480 West 42nd Street).

Timed to the 50th Anniversary of the classic musical Sweet Charity, this production stars two-time Tony Award winner Sutton Foster (“Younger,” ‘Violet,” “Anything Goes”) as Charity Hope Valentine, the sassy, diehard romantic dancehall hostess whose naivety and overeager embrace of every man she meets keeps getting her in hot water. Performed in an intimate setting with original choreography by Joshua Bergasse (“On the Town”), this production of “Sweet Charity” will be given a fresh, modern perspective by director Leigh Silverman (“Violet,” “Well”).

“Sweet Charity” is presented by The New Group in association with Kevin McCollum.

“Sweet Charity” premiered January 29, 1966 at the Palace Theatre; it was nominated for nine Tony Awards, winning one for Bob Fosse's choreography. The film adaptation, directed by Fosse, premiered in 1969; it was nominated for three Academy Awards, including Best Music, Score of a Musical Picture (Original or Adaptation). A Broadway revival opened at the Minskoff Theatre on April 27, 1986; it won four Tony Awards, including Best Revival. The 2005 Broadway revival opened at the Al Hirschfield Theatre on May 4 of that year; it was nominated for three Tony Awards, including Best Revival of a Musical. A London revival opened at the Menier Chocolate Factory on November 21, 2009 before opening at the West End's Haymarket Theatre on May 4, 2010; it received three Olivier nominations, including Best Musical Revival. The most recent major revival took place in 2014 in Sydney, Australia, as the first production of the Hayes Theatre Co.; this critically-acclaimed production transferred to Playhouse in the Sydney Opera House, where it opened January 15, 2015.

“Sweet Charity” is based on an original screenplay by Federico Fellini, Tullio Pinelli, Ennio Plaiano. Originally produced for the Broadway stage by Fryer, Carr and Harris. Conceived, Staged and Choreographed by Bob Fosse.

Winter 2017:
“Evening at the Talk House” by Wallace Shawn. Directed by Scott Elliott. Casting to be announced. Previews begin January 2017 in The Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre (480 West 42nd Street).

To celebrate the 10th anniversary of the opening of a flop play, the playwright joins the old gang to reminisce at their former haunt, The Talk House. Most haven’t been there, or even seen each other, in years, and the gossip and nostalgia are mixed with questions and accusations. Why does a washed-up old actor keep getting beaten up by his friends? Where does a failed actress-turned-waitress disappear to for months at a time? Wallace Shawn’s “Evening at the Talk House” is a biting, yet affectionate skewering of artists grasping to find their place in a world in which art has no currency and terror has become an accepted part of life. Scott Elliott directs.

This new production of “Evening at the Talk House,” a U.S. premiere, reunites Wallace Shawn and director Scott Elliott, whose previous collaborations for The New Group include Aunt Dan and Lemon, The Fever and Marie and Bruce. Evening at the Talk House premiered in November 2015 at the National Theatre.

Winter 2017:
“All the Fine Boys” written and directed by Erica Schmidt. Casting to be announced. World Premiere production begins previews February 2017 in the Ford Foundation Studio Theatre (480 West 42nd Street).

It’s suburban South Carolina in the late '80s and fourteen year-old best friends Jenny and Emily are ready to make their first serious attempts with boys. Emily chooses her senior crush from the high school play, and Jenny a man she’s seen at her family’s church. With parallel stories that take tricky and terrifying turns, “All the Fine Boys” dives deep into the fascinations and fears of sexual awakening and the first painful gasps of maturity.

Spring 2017:
“The Whirligig” by Hamish Linklater. Directed by Scott Elliott. Featuring Zosia Mamet and Maura Tierney. Additional casting to be announced. World Premiere production begins previews May 2017 in The Alice Griffin Jewel Box Theatre (480 West 42nd Street).

When, after much time away, Kristina (Maura Tierney) is back in Berkshire County, word spreads fast that she and her ex-husband are caring for their estranged, ailing daughter Julie. Broken-hearted and giddy with love and confusion, surprising visitors from Julie's complicated past, including her childhood best friend Trish (Zosia Mamet) and her former drug dealer, practically trip over each other to reach the young woman they thought they'd lost years before but still feel so deeply connected to. Heartfelt and compassionate, Hamish Linklater’s “The Whirligig” spins a tale of a fractured community weaving a circuitous route back to one another. Scott Elliott directs.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Review: “Toast” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Sunday May 22, 2016)

Photo: Matthew Kelly in "Toast. Credit: Oliver King.
Review: “Toast” at 59E59 Theaters (Through Sunday May 22, 2016)
By Richard Bean
Directed by Eleanor Rhode
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Currently running at 59E59 Theaters as part of the Brits Off-Broadway Series, Richard Bean’s 1999 “Toast” slices its way through layers of delicious intrigue to a tasty core of surprises that make the journey more than worthwhile. This is drawing room farce sans the drawing room. The swinging doors here connect the unseen bakery to the break room where the soon-to-close bakery’s crusty employees vie for attention, power, and survival.

It’s a Sunday at the bakery and Blakey (played with a soulful steely interior by Steve Nicolson) is in charge of the shift. He calls Mr. Beckett his boss to report he’s a man short and to confirm Beckett has written a letter of recommendation. In a subsequent call from Beckett, Blakey learns he and his crew need to increase their production by three thousand for another bakery. This puts the bakery in production overdrive and throws the dynamics of the group of workers into a state of psychosocial exhaustion.

Mr. Beckett sends a student to cover for the missing worker and it is the addition of Lance (played with a devilish charm by John Wark) that ultimately challenges the family system of the six workers and drives the fascinating plot of Mr. Bean’s play. It is difficult to say much about Lance other than he is a bit creepy and cherishes any time he has alone with one of the workers. And he wears a red shirt. A malfunction in the oven creates the crisis in “Toast” and the resolution comes in discovering the culprit who caused the malfunction and what motivates him. Indeed, the play centers on motivation and it is the motivation of each character that brings depth and roundness to each.

Each member of the ensemble cast delivers an authentic and believable performance. Matthew Kelly is a lumbering about-to-retire Nellie who almost gets the blame for the jammed tin that shuts down the oven. Will Barton plays the combative Colin who does little to un-jam the oven. Simon Greenall is the feisty and funny Cecil whose appears to be the moral glue for the team of bakers. Kieran Knowles provides a dizzy Dezzie who cannot remember his new address and writes his phone number on his bike helmet. Matt Sutton’s scrappy Peter volunteers to fix the oven and articulates the importance of having a job and an income.

Eleanor Rhode directs “Toast” with a keen eye for the visual and wastes no movement or pause. Designer James Turner and lighting designer Mike Robertson create a bakery with gritty realism and Holly Rose Henshaw’s costumes and Max Pappenheim’s sound bring that realism to a resounding pitch of perfection. Mr. Bean – as he always manages to accomplish – creates order out of chaos and raises enduring questions from the detritus in an overflowing bin of used teabags.


Olivier Award­winner Matthew Kelly leads the cast as Nellie. He is joined by Simon Greenall, Steve Nicolson, Will Barton, Kieran Knowles, Matt Sutton, and John Wark.

The design team includes James Turner (set design); Mike Robertson (lighting design); Max Pappenheim (composition and sound design); and Holly Rose Henshaw (costume design).

The performance schedule is Tuesday – Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; and Sunday at 3:00 p.m. Performances are at 59E59 Theaters (59 East 59th Street, between Park and Madison Avenues). Tickets are $70.00 ($49.00 for 59E59 Members). To purchase tickets, call Ticket Central at (212) 279-­4200 or visit Running time is 2 hours including one intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Review: “Kentucky” at Ensemble Studio Theatre (Through Sunday May 22, 2016)

Photo: Satomi Blair and Sasha Diamond in "Kentucky." Credit Jody Christopherson.
Review: “Kentucky” at Ensemble Studio Theatre (Through Sunday May 22, 2016)
Written by Leah Nanako Winkler
Directed by Morgan Gould
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

Armed with the promise of her therapist’s willingness to offer phone support and clutching a bottle of sedatives from the same therapist, Hiro (played with a steely vulnerability by Satomi Blair) flies from New York to Kentucky to convince her younger sister Sophie (played with a charming but confident core by Sasha Diamond) not to marry Da’Ran (played with exquisite charm and panache by Ronald Alexander Peet) the born-again Christian man she has been dating for only six months. Hiro’s journey back to the home where she was verbally abused by her father James (played with an oddly likable scrappiness by Jay Patterson) is the tragi-comic tale in Leah Nanako Winkler’s “Kentucky” currently running at Ensemble Studio Theatre and jointly produced with Page 73.

This is an epic journey for Hiro, an attempt not only to “save” her sister but to seek closure in her struggle to finalize her separation and individuation from a dysfunctional and often abusive family. Rescuing her sister will somehow complete her process of healing and redemption. Ms. Blair and the brilliant ensemble cast of “Kentucky” bring Hiro’s quest to a level of believability and authenticity while managing to allow the playwright’s humor and magical realism to counterpoint the dramatic arc of the story.

“Kentucky” successfully raises a series of important enduring questions. What is home and how does one know when one is home? How does one know he or she was loved as a child? What constitutes parental love? Is it possible for individuals with vastly different value systems to understand and accept one another? Does unconditional and non-judgmental love overcome the obstacles evident in cultural differences?

Perhaps most importantly, Hiro’s journey highlights the important issues being raised in the current Presidential Primary Election process. America’s population is widely different and often unyielding in accepting differences in ideology, culture, and religion. “Kentucky” places these issues in a framework accessible to a diverse audience and explores the possibility of mutual understanding and pervasive acceptance. Near the end of the play, Adam (Alex Grubbs) shares this: “While people like me. We are inevitably, fleeting seeking solace and reaching - fleshing ourselves out always looking into mirrors staring at her own eyes and wondering if we are losing in some ways and winning in others.”

Ms. Winkler manages to raise these questions in a morally ambiguous way. Her script makes no judgement but allows the audience member to grapple with the questions and decide what is “right” or “wrong” or if those categories are even relevant. For example, just when the audience is convinced of Hiro’s father’s total depravity, James (Jay Patterson) displays an unexpected and honest vulnerability. When the audience decides Adam (played with a scintillating and deep charm by Alex Grubbs), the character displays a rich understanding of love and relationship. When Hiro’s mother Masako (played with layered sadness by Ako) seems beyond healing, the character is able to express a deep love for her prodigal daughter.

When one of Hiro’s childhood friends Laura (played with a fragile fortitude by Emily Kunkel) takes a chance on love with Adam, she makes him an offer: “If things don’t work out with Hiro, which it won’t, call me. I make a succulent Derby Pie that’s so rich with sweetness that it’ll heal any sick heart wound and make you keep rippin’ into every part for thirds, fourths, fifths, sixths, sevenths, eighths, ninths, tenths and so on and so on and so on and so on.” Ms. Winkler’s play is much like that pie. Its sweetness is in its parts, its slices. Each scene heals the sick heart wound of a nation seeking redemption and release.

But “Kentucky” resonates with the sweet bitterness of honesty. All is not well that ends well. Relationships remain fractured. Hiro invites her best childhood friend Nicole (played with a layered and deep sadness by Megan Hill) to visit in New York City but never really keeps in touch with Nicole whose final monologue is among the most powerful in the play: “I said okay. But I didn’t mean it. And I stayed here in Kentucky. I stayed here forever Hiro. And I got cancer. And I died. And you didn’t come to my funeral. And you thought about all the memories we had together. And you lit a candle for me. From your tiny room in your crammed apartment. And you wondered if the only thing that I had in life - the closeness to people that I had here. To my blind mother. To the closeness you and I once had-was missing from your own. And you went to bed. And you don’t think about me that much mostly.”
Perhaps the most enduring of “Kentucky’s” questions is whether or not we can survive as a nation if we fail to even think of one another in any significant way.


“Kentucky” features Ako, Satomi Blair, Mikumari Caiyhe, Curran Connor, Merissa Czyz, Sasha Diamond, Lynnette R. Freeman, Alex Grubbs, Marcia Haufrecht, Emily Kunkel, Jay Patterson, Ronald Alexander Peet, Samantha Sembler, Shannon Tyo, and Amir Wachterman as Sylvie.

“Kentucky” features scenic design by Nick Francone, costume design by Suzanne Chesney, lighting design by Ryan Seelig, sound design by Shane Rettig, choreography by Katie Spelman, and musical direction by Sariva Goetz. Joe Lankheet serves as production manager, and production stage manager is Eileen Lalley. Production photos by Jody Christopherson.

For complete production information, including performance schedule and ticket information, please visit Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes with one intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, May 17, 2016

Review: “The Sensuality Party” at the New Group at Baruch College (Closed Friday May 13, 2016)

Pictured: Jake Horowitz, right, in Justin Kuritzkes’ “The Sensuality Party.” Photo credit: Hunter Canning.
Review: “The Sensuality Party” at the New Group at Baruch College (Closed Friday May 13, 2016)
By Justin Kuritzkes
Directed by Danya Taymor
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

The main issue with playwright Justin Kuritzkes’ new work “The Sensuality Party” is that it seriously lacks sensuality and it certainly is no party. In fact, perhaps the young author needs to get out more, see a few things, interact and experience what might be happening since the earlier sexual revolution that he (through Speaker’s words) actually claims to not understand. If the “F” word is severely overused in this script for shock value, then New Yorkers experience free shock treatment while walking down the street every day. We have all been desensitized to vulgar language long ago. A mantra of the sixties was “relax, it’s just vibrations of the vocal chords.” Mr. Kuritzkes’ script comes off as bad porn, neither relevant, ground breaking, nor sensual. The writing is less than imaginative. The presentation is more storytelling than actual events and lacks any dramatic arc or character development. In this case, anyone could be telling the story or reciting a memory play. Possibly a better option would have been giving each patron headsets and a private room where they could listen so they could react in any self-serving way they chose.

What the performance I attended accomplished was to thoroughly disengage theatergoers from the material. I watched several restless audience members staring at watches, sleeping, plugging their ears with their fingers, texting, and even reading from their I phones. Those attempting to involve themselves could be seen stretching their necks to get a glimpse of the actor speaking only to be disappointed and disinterested a minute later, owing to the fact that there was really nothing to see. An uncomfortable forced laughter could be intermittently heard as the audience nervously tried to retrieve some kind of humor from the pretentious script.

If theater as we know it is a collaboration of different theatrical skills to produce the finished dramatic product, then the importance of scenic, sound and lighting design as well as other theatrical elements should not be eliminated - especially when a script cannot stand on its own merit. This is not a site specific production by any stretch of the imagination. Any descriptive action takes place in a dorm room or in the actor’s mind.

If the point of the playwright is to examine and show how desensitized his present generation might be, it is certainly redundant. All one has to do is walk down the street, watch how members of that generation behave in coffee shops, see how they seem incapable of connecting other than texting, add a hefty dose of narcissism, bad manners, and a diffused system of values and there you have it. You don’t need a sensuality party to realize how cold, self-indulgent, indifferent and out of touch much of the Millennial generation appears to be. Simply put this play is 95 minutes too long.


The Sensuality Party features Catherine Combs, Jeff Cuttler, Katherine Folk-Sullivan, Jake Horowitz, Layla Khoshnoudi, and Rowan Vickers. This production includes Costume Design by Beth Goldenberg. Production photos by Hunter Canning.

“The Sensuality Party” closed with the Friday May 13 performance reviewed above. For more information on The New Group and “The Sensuality Party” please visit Running time 1 hour 35 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, May 16, 2016

Review: “A Better Place” at The Duke On 42nd Street (Through Saturday June 11, 2016)

John Fitzgibbon and Rob Maitner star in Wendy Beckett's A Better Place, directed by Evan Bergman, for the Directors Company at the Duke on 42nd Street.
Review: “A Better Place” at The Duke On 42nd Street (Through Saturday June 11, 2016)
By Wendy Beckett
Directed by Evan Bergman
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

The current offering from The Director’s Company is a world premiere penned by Australian playwright Wendy Beckett entitled “A Better Place.” It turns out to be an urban synonym for the old suburban aphorism “the grass is always greener.” Only in this case, rather than a healthier lawn, it is a larger apartment in a luxury high rise in Manhattan. This script manages to successfully identify the basic human nature in today’s society that one is never satisfied with what they have or where they are. They always want to be in “a better place.” Unfortunately, this particular journey to get there is long, slow and predictable, offering no new insight and executed by stereotypical characters that are one dimensional. Direction by Evan Bergman seems forced at times, dealing with repetitive situations and trying to utilize dead space in empty apartments when the action is happening across the way. The scenic design of dual apartments across the street from each other by David L. Arsenault is beautifully created and spot on but, by no fault of his own, it actually overpowers the production.

The metaphor is blatant as the plot unfolds that unless you as a person are not in a good place moving to a bigger and better apartment will not change anything. The other problem that exists is the reality of some of the situations that try to drive the action forward. Very few people living in a rent controlled, doorman building in Manhattan would ever want to leave. There really is no better place. The $96,000-dollar windfall would not even cover the deposit on a closet in Manhattan, let alone leave anything to cover maintenance, taxes and insurance. The best you could hope for would be a new wardrobe, a few dinners with a Broadway show and a nice vacation. After almost all is resolved the slacker daughter is able to find a job and afford her own apartment after mom and dad sell and retire to Florida. It should all be that easy. All that said the dialogue does not move the plot or define the characters. Who cares if anyone ends up in a better place!

The cast does what they can to entertain, usually relying on forced comedic situations but there are too many obstacles to overcome so they succumb to stereotypes to produce humor. New York is a city filled with a tapestry of unique, very interesting people not concerned with suburban ideals. There are too many other opportunities and distractions. If this “better place” were located somewhere other than Manhattan perhaps it might be a bit more palatable. It just falls short of capturing a NYC state of mind.


The cast of A Better Place features Jessica DiGiovanni, John FitzGibbon, Judith Hawking, Edward James Hyland, Rob Maitner, and Michael Satow. The creative team includes David Arsenault (scenic design), Russell H. Champa (lighting design), Valerie Marcus Ramshur (costume design), and Sam Kunetz (sound design). Production photos by Jenny Anderson.

“A Better Place” will play Tuesdays-Thursdays at 7:00 p.m. and Fridays and Saturdays at 8:00 p.m., with matinees on Saturdays at 2:00 p.m. and Sundays at 3:00 p.m. Tickets for all performances are $55.00 and are now on sale at, by calling 646-223-3010, and in person at the Duke on 42nd Street box office (229 West 42nd Street, between 7th and 8th Avenues). The running time is 90 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, May 16, 2016

Review: Butterfly at 59E59 Theaters (Through Saturday May 14, 2016)

Photo L-R: Naomi Livingstone, Ramesh Meyyappan and Chris Alexander in "Butterfly," part of Brits Off Broadway at 59E59 Theaters. Photo by Carol Rosegg
Review: Butterfly at 59E59 Theaters (Through Saturday May 14, 2016)
Adapted from John Luther Long’s Short Story Madame Butterfly
Adapted and Directed by Ramesh Meyyappan
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

The only barrier between immersing oneself in Ramesh Meyyappan’s brilliant “Butterfly” is attempting to connect the wordless well-choreographed “dance” of love, betrayal, and redemption with its namesake “Madame Butterfly” or with the interesting connections to the lepidopterist Vladimir Nabokov. One needs to grapple with the piece itself and accept it as a unique piece of experimental theatre replete with stunning imagery and engaging music by David Paul Jones.

Naomi Livingstone is the protagonist Butterfly who constructs kites and sells them from her shop. When the Customer (played with sinister overtones by Chris Alexander) pushes his interest in kites to interest in their maker too far, Butterfly rejects his advances and he eventually returns and assaults her sexually. Nabokov (played with a naïve cunning by Ramesh Meyyappan) offers Butterfly an avenue of escape in collecting butterflies – a trope that easily connects with his interest in Butterfly herself and her journey to self-discovery and self-fulfillment. Butterfly’s engagement with the two men (are they one and the same perhaps?) is told with stylized movement, imaginative puppetry, and stark dream sequences that take the audience deep into Butterfly’s non-conscious reflections on love and motherhood. What is real and what is not keeps the piece interesting and Mr. Meyyappan’s direction keeps the piece moving and accessible.

Played without words, “Butterfly” depends heavily on symbolism and the ability of the actors to portray emotion successfully with only facial and body expressions. Mr. Meyyappan, Ms. Livingstone, and Mr. Alexander successfully navigate this terrain and deliver authentic and compelling performances. They bring kite-flying, butterflies, and Butterfly’s child to stunning realism – thanks to the brilliant craft of puppet maker Gavin Glover. Kudos to Ms. Livingstone whose emotional range is stunning and breathtaking.

Butterfly’s loss of love (Nabokov appears, disappears, and reappears with a knapsack on his back) and the ways she sustains herself until love reappears or reimagines makes for a wonderful story. There are two more opportunities to see “Butterfly” at 59E59 Theaters and the effort to see one of those performances is well worth the effort.


“Butterfly” features Chris Alexander, Naomi Livingstone, and Ramesh Meyyappan. The design team includes Neil Warmington (set and costume design) and Kate Bonney (lighting design). The choreographer is Darren Brownlie. The production stage manager is Cressa Amundsen. Production photos by Carol Rosegg.

The remaining performances are on Saturday May 14 at 2:30 p.m. and 8:30 p.m. Performances are at 59E59 Theaters (59 East 59th Street, between Park and Madison Avenues). Tickets are $25.00 ($17.50 for 59E59 Members). To purchase tickets, call Ticket Central at (212) 279-4200 or visit Running time is 60 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, May 13, 2016

Review: “You Are Now the Owner of This Suitcase” at Theatre 167 at the West End Theatre

Review: “You Are Now the Owner of This Suitcase” at Theatre 167 at the West End Theatre
By Mando Alvarado, Jenny Lyn Bader, Barbara Cassidy, Les Hunter, Joy Tomasko, Gary Winter, and Stefanie Zadravec
Conceived and Directed by Ari Laura Kreith
Reviewed by Joseph Verlezza
Theatre Reviews Limited

“You Are Now the Owner of This Suitcase” is a modern day folktale, comprised of 21 scenes, with contributions from seven different playwrights, with an objective to meld a multiplicity of styles into one voice. It goes hand in hand with the mission of the producing company, Theatre 167, to create, cultivate and support new works by artists of wide ranging backgrounds traditions and beliefs. Their name refers to the 167 languages spoken in the community in which they were born, depicted in this magical and mystical tale, as Enchanted Jackson Heights.

Right from the start, as the audience is pleasantly serenaded by a street musician playing guitar and singing in different languages, you become aware of the first obstacle this production must overcome; namely, the inferior acoustics of the space. Sound drifts in and out depending on vocal direction and projection. This combined with the heavy accents afforded by the actors in order to elaborate the different cultures, the speed at which dialogue was delivered and poor projection, made it difficult at times to understand the actors.

There is really nothing wrong with the story. It is a simple, charming parable to express hope, the power of dreams, the importance of trust and the significance of unconditional acceptance and love. Add a spark of mysticism and magic realism and it becomes entertainment that can please a diverse and multi- generational audience. But in order for this to happen on stage the crucial element is a good storyteller, and that is where the second problem comes into play. As told in this production, it becomes a series of fragmented fairy tales, with difficulty in connecting scenes with fluidity and cohesiveness. Perhaps the lost preshow balladeer could have become the connective tissue needed to guide the audience through this complicated journey, if even with just his strolling guitar music weaving transitions more tightly.

The admirable but uneven cast exhibits an earnest attempt but falls short of attaining their goal. Some of this may be attributed to the direction which seems to be sporadic. It is a special type of fairy tale where real people integrate with fantasized events, and must be handled very delicately. The actors succumb to too many stereotypes, at times almost caricatures and the aforementioned heavy accents almost contribute to that problem. The heavy handedness also delineates the characters as being too familiar in the genre, whereas more original depictions would lend themselves to the inspired story.
I applaud Theatre 167 for their integrity and mission. I revere the cast for their dedication, perseverance, and craft. Go and experience this current production and support part of the rich theater scene we are so fortunate to have in this great city.


“You Are Now the Owner of This Suitcase” features Mariana Cardenas, Tori Ernst, Nathaniel Gotbaum, John D. Haggerty, Kevis Hillocks, Michael Markham, Elodie Morss, Mauricio Pita, and Derick James Sherrier. Set design is by Jen Price Fick; lighting by Jason Fok; costumes by Jessa-Raye Court; projections by Arthur Vincie and sound by Andy Evan Cohen.

“You Are Now the Owner of This Suitcase” is performed through May 1 at the West End Theatre at the Church of Saint Paul and St. Andrew (263 W 86th Street b/w West End Ave. and Broadway). Take the 1 train to the 86th Street stop. Full price tickets are $18.00 and $16.00 for students and seniors. For performance schedule and to purchase tickets, visit Running time is 1 hour and 10 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Monday, April 11, 2016

Review: “The Father” at Manhattan Theatre Club’s Samuel J. Friedman Theatre

Pictured (L-R): Frank Langella and Kathryn Erbe. Credit Joan Marcus.
By Florian Zeller, and Translated by Christopher Hampton
Directed by Doug Hughes
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“With Blue – uncertain stumbling Buzz – Between the light – and me – And then the Windows failed – and then I could not see to see.” (Emily Dickenson, “I heard a Fly buzz” – No. 465)
Anne (Kathryn Erbe) was “scared of [her father André] when [she] was little.” In the present – as he battles his advanced Alzheimer’s – André is more childlike, requesting Anne sing him to sleep with a lullaby. “The Father,” currently running at Manhattan Theatre Club’s Samuel J. Friedman Theatre, is playwright Florian Zeller’s seductive chronicle of the decline of a father deteriorating from Alzheimer’s and his daughter’s attempts to cope with his decline and with her overwhelming sense of loss and despair.

Unable to care for himself, and having threatened his caregiver Isabelle with a curtain rod, André (Frank Langella) moves into Anne’s flat with her husband Pierre (Brian Avers). In a series of sharply focused scenes, the seriousness of André’s condition becomes clear. He is not only forgetful, he is delusional, he experiences hallucinations, and he is beset with paranoia. Although he is able to be “charming” when he meets his new caregiver Laura (Hannah Cabell), his debilitating condition – which he denies – continues to weaken him and render him even more helpless. He confuses past and present, confuses the identity of the people around him, and withdraws further into an abyss of melancholy and loneliness. The scenes are separated by total blackouts and bright flashing lights surrounding the proscenium. This lighting design by Donald Holder mimics the brain’s electrical impulses firing and misfiring, seeking patterns of normalcy and healing and surcease from suffering – neurotransmitters that fail to fully cooperate or simply fail altogether.

Under Doug Hughes’ exacting and brilliant direction, the ensemble cast successfully creates a pantheon of characters that, depending on one’s point of view, are real or unreal. Their interaction with André is often disturbing and one wonders for instance whether the disturbing scene with the Man (Charles Borland) abusing André is purely delusional or whether it is reminiscent of some actual elder abuse by a caregiver or even by Anne or Pierre. Mr. Borland and Kathleen McNenny (the Woman) appear in scenes as – in André’s mind –Pierre and Anne. Kathryn Erbe captivates the audience in her performance as Anne, flawlessly transmuting the love of a daughter to and from the despair and anger of a frustrated primary giver of care. And Brian Avers balances his character Pierre’s respect for André with his impatience at his longevity and languorous presence.

Frank Langella’s performance as André is mesmerizing. He slowly peels away the layers of an insidious disease with a remarkable tenderness and vulnerability. He is the perfect choice for this role and one wonders if anyone could portray André with the same authenticity and believability. He balances humor with pathos in uncanny ways that challenge the audience to wonder whether their laughter is appropriate or unsuitable. Is it really funny, for example, that a distinguished older man who has always lived with dignity, forgets he was an engineer and convinces his new caregiver he was a tap dancer?

André’s missing watch is the perfect metaphor for the delusional behavior and the paranoia present in individuals with Alzheimer’s. Playwright Florian Zeller focuses the symptomology of André’s advanced dementia on his watch. When he cannot find it, André admonishes Anne’s disbelief with, “What do you mean, "no, it hasn't"? The watch must be somewhere! It can't have flown away! So why do you say "no, it hasn't"? Why do you say that, when it very well might have been stolen? My watch.”

Scott Pask’s stunning Parisian flat set doubles as an equally stunning trope for the disintegration of André’s memory and mind. Aided by illusion consultant Jim Steinmeyer, Mr. Pask creates a striking set which slowly morphs from a beautifully decorated flat with a high end kitchen and tasteful furnishings into a bare hospital room with only a bed. Catherine Zuber’s costumes and Fitz Patton’s original music and sound complement the set design with tasteful perfection.

One should not ignore Florian Zeller’s subtitle for “The Father.” The playwright identifies it as a tragic farce, a theatrical genre somewhat specific to a “new generation” of French playwrights akin to Beckett and Ianesco but who move beyond the confines of Absurdism and Existentialism to an "age of interpellation" that “reflects a larger trend in French literature in general, known as auto-fiction – a fiction whose creation is based on ‘facts’ and that serves as a conduit into the subconscious.” (Scott D. Taylor, “French Tragic Farce in an Age of Interpellation,” from “Modern Drama, Volume 51, Number 2, Summer 2008). Christopher Hampton’s translation of Mr. Zeller’s script handily plunges into the subconscious.

In “The Father” – as in the play’s pairing “The Mother” – Mr. Zeller constructs a fascinating puzzle for the audience to decipher. Solving the puzzle requires the audience to understand “The Father” is a point-of-view play. Mr. Zeller successfully provides the audience with a variety of points-of-view: André’s, his daughter Anne’s, and her husband Pierre’s (“or something along that line” as André describes Pierre). The audience leaves the theatre wondering which point of view might have been most accurate. The audience also exits the theatre with a new understanding of a disease where the familiar becomes unfamiliar, friends become enemies, and the worst nightmare possible becomes reality.


The cast of “The Father” includes Brian Avers, Charles Borland, Hannah Cabell, Kathryn Erbe, Frank Langella, and Kathleen McNenny.

The creative team for “The Father” includes: Scott Pask (scenic design), Catherine Zuber (costume design), Donald Holder (lighting design), Fitz Patton (original music and sound design), and Jim Steinmeyer (illusion consultant). Production photos are by Joan Marcus.

Tickets for “The Father” are available by calling Telecharge at 212-239-6200, online by visiting, or by visiting the Samuel J. Friedman Theatre Box Office (261 West 47th Street). Ticket prices are $70-$150. Running time is 90 minutes
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Saturday, April 9, 2016

Review: “Nathan the Wise” at Classic Stage Company (Through Sunday May 1, 2016)

Photo: F. Murray Abraham and George Abud. Credit Richard Termine.
Review: “Nathan the Wise” at Classic Stage Company (Through Sunday May 1, 2016)
By Gotthold Ephraim Lessing and Adapted by Edward Kemp
Directed by Brian Kulick
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

The Jerusalem of 1192 in Gotthold Ephraim Lessing’s “Nathan the Wise,” currently running at Classic Stage Company, is not unlike the Jerusalem of the present: still a divided city with the three major world religions vying for supremacy and claiming with pride a unique claim on being the “sole purveyors of divine revelation.” The Templar (Stark Sands) admonishes Nathan (F. Murray Abraham), “Fine words. But which nation was the first to set itself apart? To say, 'We are the Chosen People.' Well, Nathan? This may not be grounds for hatred, I admit, but can't I still condemn you for your pride? The pride with which you have infected Christian and Muslim alike, to say My G-d Alone Is Right.”

Lessing’s play – more in the style of a late play by Shakespeare than in his contemporary German style – is complex. Its characters are well-rounded and interesting; their conflicts engaging and relevant to the theme of the equality of all religions. Although Jerusalem in 1192 was experiencing a “brief and rare period of peaceful accord between the Muslim, Christian, and Jewish communities,” the key players of each community were involved in anti-Muslim, anti-Christian, and anti-Jewish enterprises elsewhere and the repercussions of those escapades ricocheted between members of the three communities in Jerusalem. These conflicts drive the captivating plot that includes a treasure trove of Shakespearean conventions: mistaken identities; love at first sight; soliloquies; and dramatic irony. There are even moments when one wonders whether Nathan the Wise is delivering lines in iambic pentameter!

It is impossible to rehearse the plot in any detail without disclosing important events that carefully prepare for the play’s surprise ending. It is enough to say that Nathan is the play’s gatekeeper who negotiates, bargains, confounds, and energizes the rest of the characters. Nathan is the play’s moral compass although even he is tempted sometimes by exclusive loyalty to his faith. F. Murray Abraham’s performance as Nathan is nothing short of brilliant and the quintessence of exquisite acting. Mr. Abraham is fully present in every moment he is on stage. His character charms his adopted daughter Rachel (Erin Neufer), Daya the Christian servant in his house (Caroline Lagerfelt) and constantly attempts to negotiate peace between Saladin (Austin Durant), the Patriarch (Caroline Lagerfelt) and the Brother (John Christopher Jones), the Templar (Stark Sands) who rescues his daughter from a fire after being spared by Saladin, and the “Jester” of the cast Al-Hafi (George Abud).

The play’s turning point comes when Nathan responds to Saladin’s challenge to identify “which code, which law, which faith have you found most enlightening?” Nathan tells the iconic story of the rings as his answer and provides the clear purpose for Lessing’s play: “Maybe this was your father's plan, to end the tyranny of the single ring. It's clear he loved you all, and loved you equally: why should he disadvantage two by favoring one? You could do worse than follow his example, strive towards such unprejudiced affection in yourselves. Vie with each other to prove the power of your ring, through gentleness, tolerance, charity, and a deep humility before the love of G-d.”

Under Brian Kulick’s artful and efficient direction, the equally accomplished ensemble cast successfully negotiates Lessing’s path to forgiveness and reconciliation embodying Nathan’s words, “Because G-d rewards the good we do on earth on earth as well. And you must learn this: dreams are easy, deeds are hard. Imagine angels all you like but let them inspire you to action, not distract you from it.” Tony Straiges’ set, Anita Yavich’s language and symbol coded costumes, and Joe Novak’s lighting all serve to give the production a splendid effulgence.

At the beginning of the play, Saladin introduces the play and the cast of characters in modern Arabic. Some members of the audience understand; however, the majority sit in silence waiting to somehow be rescued. It is difficult to understand when one’s own language is not being spoken and heard. Language and religion are closely connected in “Nathan the Wise” and much of what confounds the residents of Jerusalem in 1192 continues to confound the global community in the present. Failure to understand leads to fanaticism and intolerance which are both dangerous and insidious companions.

Perhaps the Templar summarized the dilemma best, ““I don't believe we ever lose the superstitions of our race. We drink them in with our mother's milk, and we may mock them but they are bred into our bones.” But Saladin’s words are those that give us hope, “Above all say nothing of this to the fanatics of your faith. Never be a Christian to spite a Jew. Or a Muslim.” Therein lies hope for tolerance and peace.


The cast of “Nathan the Wise” includes F. Murray Abraham, George Abud, Austin Durant, John Christopher Jones, Shiva Kalaiselvan, Caroline Lagerfelt, Erin Neufer and Stark Sands. Set design is by Tony Straiges, costumes by Anita Tavich, lighting by Joe Novak and sound by Matt Stine. Production photos by Richard Termine.

“Nathan the Wise” will perform Tuesdays through Thursdays at 7:00 p.m.; Fridays and Saturdays at 8:00 p.m. and Sundays at 3:00 p.m. Tickets are $60.00 on weeknights and $65.00 on weekends and are available at or by calling (212) 352-3101 / 866-811-4111 or at the box-office at 136 East 13th Street, New York City (between Third and Fourth Avenues). Running time is two hours with one intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Saturday, April 9, 2016

Review: “Exit Strategy” at Primary Stages at the Cherry Lane Theatre (Through Friday May 6, 2016)

(from left) Brandon J. Pierce and Ryan Spahn in the Primary Stages production of Exit Strategy by Ike Holter, directed by Kip Fagan, at Primary Stages at the Cherry Lane Theatre. (c) James Leynse.
Review: “Exit Strategy” at Primary Stages at the Cherry Lane Theatre (Through Friday May 6, 2016)
By Ike Holter
Directed by Kip Fagan
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“After great pain, a formal feeling comes -/The Nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs -/The stiff Heart questions was it He, that bore, And Yesterday, or Centuries before?” (Emily Dickinson, #341)

Educators and academics have been trying to determine why schools fail for decades and have yet to identify successfully a formula for preventing the pandemic failure of education – particularly in America’s urban centers. Although Ike Holter’s luminous “Exit Strategy” is set in a failing high school somewhere in Chicago, the playwright avoids the temptation to address the larger issues of school failure – teachers, parents, systems, testing – and narrowly focuses on the exit strategies of seven individuals who discover their high school has one academic year left before being closed and bulldozed. Five teachers have their exit interviews with the school Tumbldn’s Vice Principal Ricky (Ryan Spahn) during the August prior to this terminal year. Only four teachers return in September and they and the Vice Principal are joined by an overzealous graduating senior for the nine-month rehearsal for the school’s final act.

“Exit Strategy” covers the ten-month period from the Exit Strategy Interviews on August 16th through June 16th - several days after the end of the school year. The action take place in Vice Principal Ricky’s office and in the Teacher’s Lounge. The set is designed with authentic detail by Andrew Boyce – the administrator’s office done up nicely and the teacher’s lounge infested with rats and lighted by those fluorescent lights that always seems to need new tubes or new starters. For ninety mind-splitting minutes, the six “survivors” squabble, bargain, organize, and grapple with fate, hoping to keep the school open and their lives salvaged from insignificance.

Arnold (played with a stolid and often reprehensible resignation by Michael Cullen) is the union representative who holds out for the victory of old school norms and prepares to let the City of Chicago win. Senior Donnie (played with an authentic youthful hope by Brandon J. Pierce) hacks into the school’s computer system, sets up an Ingiegogo fundraising page, and manages to inspire Ricky to work with him to fight the system. Sadie (played with a strident veneer but a caring core by Aimé Donna Kelly) and Jania (played with a combative but crumbling façade by Christina Nieves) cannot extricate themselves from their dislike for one another but decide to join the fight for what is right. And Luce (played with a compelling unconditional love by Rey Lucas) serves as the moral center of the group and Ricky’s faithful lover. They manage to organize a parade of “thousands” but their success in protest fails to move the monolithic heart of stone of the Chicago Public Schools.

Ike Holter’s script is richly complex with just the right number of surprises tucked away in the well-rounded characters’ Pandora’s Box of authentic conflicts. Kip Fagan’s staging is fast-paced, energetic, deeply engaging, and unravels each of the playwright’s episodic emotion-laden salvos with subtle seduction. Daniel Perelstein’s sound design is a cacophony of conscience that separates each scene, startles the audience with impassioned sensibility each time the lights come back up, and leaves the audience with no exit strategy from connecting with the extended catharsis of the play.

The City of Chicago apparently takes no prisoners in its battle with “failing” schools and that is certainly the case in “Exit Strategy.” After veteran English Teacher Pam (played with remarkable authenticity and genuine grit by Deirdre Madigan) takes her own life in her office after her interview in August, the entire school begins to mourn not only her loss but their loss: the loss of a colleague; the loss of their school; the loss of opportunities to care more and connect more with one another and their students; the loss of hope; and the loss of trust.

Nothing is the same for Arnold, Sadie, Luce, Jania, Donnie, or Ricky after the death of their colleague and the closure of their school. Some are able to move on and form new relationships. Others – stuck for a time in a matrix of grief and denial – wait for an opportunity to recover from their loss and reboot their lives and careers. But all are embraced by that formal feeling that comes after great pain so beautifully captured in Donnie’s face as the curtain goes down for the final time.


The cast of “Exit Strategy” includes Michael Cullen, Aimé Donna Kelly, Rey Lucas, Deirdre Madigan, Christina Nieves, Brandon J. Pierce, and Ryan Spahn.

“Exit Strategy” features scenic design by Andrew Boyce, costume design by Jessica Pabst, lighting design by Thom Weaver, sound design by Daniel Perelstein, with casting by Klapper Casting. Production photos by James Leynse.

“Exit Strategy” plays a limited engagement through May 6, 2016 at Primary Stages at the Cherry Lane Theatre (38 Commerce Street, Performances are Tuesday - Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; Sun 3:00 p.m. There is an added 2:00 p.m. performance on Wednesday, May 4. No performances April 19, 26, and May 3. Tickets are $70 and can be purchased online at, by phone via OvationTix at 212.352.3101 or toll-free 866.811.4111 (9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Monday to Friday and 10:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Saturday and Sunday), or at the box office. Running time is 95 minutes without intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Friday, April 8, 2016

Review: “Cagney” Taps at the Heart at the Westside Theatre - Upstairs

(Left to right) Bruce Sabath, Ellen Zolezzi, Jeremy Benton, Robert Creighton, Danette Holden and Josh Walden. Credit Carol Rosegg.
Review: “Cagney” Taps at the Heart at the Westside Theatre - Upstairs
Book by Peter Colley
Music and Lyrics by Robert Creighton and Christopher McGovern
Arrangements by Christopher McGovern
Directed by Bill Castellino
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“Cagney, you're playing the lead now. Got to carry the picture. Don't screw it up. Now get back on set. Oh, and Cagney - give me more of that grapefruit stuff!” (Jack Warner in “Cagney”)

Although “Cagney” has been playing since 2009 and has ostensibly been updated, expanded, and revised, the musical still needs some tweaking to bring it to its next and highest level. The cast is uniformly brilliant: what a collection of Broadway triple-threat actors! The problem might be that the five performers are simply working too hard. Each is required to play a variety (and quite a variety it is) of other characters. Despite this, these five hard-working actors deliver strong performances in this musical that pays tribute to James Cagney and the indomitable spirit of the Nation he loved unconditionally.

The musical is set backstage at the SAG (Screen Actors Guild) Lifetime Achievement Awards in 1978 hosted by Jack Warner (Bruce Sabath). “Cagney” traces the actor’s life and career in a series of flashbacks that occur in James Cagney’s mind. These include Cagney’s (Robert Creighton) early days on the streets of New York where he struggled to support Ma Cagney (Danette Holden) and his younger brother Bill (Josh Walden); his stint on the vaudeville circuit; his meteoric rise to fame in Hollywood; his appearance before the Dies Committee in Washington. D.C.; his appearance at a USO show; and on sound stages in Hollywood.

Robert Creighton is simply splendid as James Cagney. It is not just that he looks like the iconic actor: Mr. Creighton embodies Cagney in a purely distilled form that oozes authenticity and honesty. His music and lyrics – as well as those of Christopher McGovern – chronicle Cagney’s fascinating story with integrity. Although the music is stronger than the lyrics, the lyrics remain serviceable and ring with honesty. Jeremy Benton is an engaging Bob Hope. Danette Holden’s Ma Cagney is appropriately tough with her love; her Jane (Warner’s Assistant) – through no fault of her own – is more a cartoon than a character. The audience sees more of Jack Warner than James Cagney and Bruce Sabath embodies the stingy curmudgeon with a steely core. Unfortunately, as is the case with Jane, the book and direction give the character an unfortunate cartoonish veneer, a choice this critic simply cannot understand.

Josh Walden and Ellen Zolezzi deliver strong performances as Cagney’s wife and brother respectively. Again, their requirement to play so many additional roles keeps them from developing their individual characters as deeply as they are capable of doing. Both are superb singers and dancers as well, and they – and the rest of the cast – are capable of more intricate and inventive choreography than provided by veteran Joshua Bergasse whose somewhat pedestrian choreography here becomes repetitive and bromidic.

Now to the creative team: you are all “playing the lead now” and on a new journey with an open run playing to houses of appreciative patrons. Time to get back around the table and give those devotees “more of that grapefruit stuff.” Add a small ensemble cast that can play all of the minor roles so the principals can dig deeper into their main character roles. The audience, for example, does not need to see the talented Jeremy Benton playing Bob Hope and a camera man. Develop a better book. Director Bill Castellino does what he can with Peter Colley’s tepid book that totters between a bio-musical and musical comedy. And hire a wig and hair designer: the actors deserve professionally designed and maintained wigs that will not make them seem like caricatures.

In its present form, “Cagney” is highly entertaining and well worth a trip to the iconic Westside Theatre. The cast’s performances of George M. Cohan’s “Grand Old Flag” and “Yankee Doodle Dandy” not only bring down the house; they also link the two Irish song-and-dance-men in a matrix of wonder that serves as a fitting surcease to the contemporary malaise of a nation – and a world – that struggles to know how they “will be remembered.”


The cast of “Cagney” includes Jeremy Benton, Robert Creighton, Dannette Holden, Bruce Sabath, Josh Walden, and Ellen Zolezzi.

The creative team includes James Morgan (set), Chip Schoonmaker (costumes), Michael Gilliam (lights), Janie Bullard (sound), and Mark Pirolo (projections). The Production Stage Manager is Larry Smiglewski. Carol Hanzel is the Casting Director and Brierpatch Productions provides General Management. Production photos by Carol Rosegg.

“Cagney” runs at the Westside Theatre - Upstairs (407 West 43rd Street) on the following performance schedule: Tuesday at 7:00 p.m., Wednesday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m., Thursday and Friday at 8:00 p.m., Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m. and Sunday at 3:00 p.m. Tickets for “Cagney” are priced at $89 and may be purchased by calling Telecharge: 212-239-6200, or by visiting Running time is 2 hours and 20 minutes including a fifteen-minute intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Review: “Bright Star” Celebrates Hope at the Cort Theatre

Photo: Carmen Cusack and the "Bright Star" Company. Credit Nick Stokes.
Review: “Bright Star” Celebrates Hope at the Cort Theatre
Music, Book and Original Story by Steve Martin
Music, Lyrics and Original Story by Edie Brickell
Directed by Walter Bobbie
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

“And I understood that truth seeks us out - then walks beside us like a shadow, and one day it merges
with us. Until it does, we are not truly whole.” (Billy to Miss Murphy)

Steve Martin and Edie Brickell’s “Bright Star” is a welcomed infusion of optimism into the veins of the Broadway stage and a delightful breath of fresh air in the current theatrical season. It is an old fashioned Broadway musical with pleasing music, agreeable lyrics, and an engaging book that celebrates the strength of the human spirit and the redemptive power of unconditional and nonjudgmental love – a celebration of storytelling and the themes that undergird the importance of hope.

Because the characters in “Bright Star” are well-rounded and have universal conflicts that the audience can easily identify and connect with, the musical’s story is also universal and engaging. Its themes are important and life affirming. Portraying events in two different time periods can be a daunting task but Steve Martin and Edie Brickell succeed in counterpointing Billy Cane’s (A. J. Shively) and Alice Murphy’s (Carmen Cusack) journey across two decades to find what has been missing in their lives. Their stories are complicated and better left for the audience to unravel. It is enough to say that the stories develop in interesting ways with wonderful surprises and address the wonderful gift of a truth that “seeks us out” until “it merges with us” making us “truly whole.”

The cast, under Walter Bobbie’s careful direction is uniformly magnificent – wonderful to watch and outstanding to hear. Broadway newcomer Carmen Cusack knows how to deliver a country song and, right from the beginning, her Alice Murphy commands the stage and massages the hearts of the audience with authentic joy and hopefulness. Ms. Cusack shines in “If You Knew My Story,” “Sun Is Gonna Shine,” “So Familiar,” and “At Long Last.” A. J. Shively’s performance as Billy Cane is multi-layered and honest to the core. Mr. Shively delivers “Always Will” with tenderness and understanding. Paul Alexander Nolan has the difficult task of portraying Jimmy Ray Dobbs a complex character whose motives are conflicted, at times reprehensible, but ultimately redemptive. Mr. Nolan succeeds and delivers an authentic character capable of growth and grace. His “Heartbreaker” is honest and genuine.

Stephen Bogardus portrays Daddy Cane with honesty and believability. His early first act tribute to his character’s loss (with A. J. Shively) is an emotional anchor for the scene. One longs to hear more from this vocalist in the musical. Emily Padgett (Lucy Grant), Michael Mulheren (Mayor Josiah Dobbs), and Hannah Elless (Margo Crawford) all add their considerable craft to the success of “Bright Star.” Stephen Lee Anderson and Dee Hoty handle the complex characters Daddy Murphy and Mama Murphy with refined performances, particularly evidenced in “Firmer Hand/Do Right” and “Please Don’t Take Him.”

The ensemble transfixes the audience as the members execute Josh Rhodes’ exquisite choreography with a superb gracefulness and energy. Mr. Rhodes’ work does not merely complement the action of the musical, his movement is a character with a soul and a purpose. Eugene Lee’s scenic design works primarily because of the energy of the ensemble cast who move sets on and off seamlessly. The house-cum-bandstand sometimes seems intrusive but manages to complement the action most of the time. Jane Greenwood is an icon. Her costumes here are able to span two decades with subtle changes in hue, color, and design and with marvelous movement that counterpoint the choreography with perfection. And Japhy Weideman creates pure magic with his transcendent lighting that creates space and mood and memories.

“Bright Star” is not perfect – some of the story seems contrived and sometimes predictable – but director Walter Bobbie keeps the musical moving forward with an intensity and freshness that is remarkable and noteworthy. There are scenes that are pure magic and utilize the skills of the cast and creative team in perfect harmony. Alice Murphy’s story is one you will celebrate knowing and come away loving and remembering.


The cast of “Bright Star” includes Stephen Lee Anderson, Jeff Blumenkrantz, Stephen Bogardus, Carmen Cusack, Hannah Elless, Dee Hoty, Michael Mulheren, Paul Alexander Nolan, Emily Padgett, and A.J. Shively along with Maddie Shea Baldwin, Allison Briner-Dardenne, Max Chernin, Patrick Cummings, Sandra DeNise, Richard Gatta, Lizzie Klemperer, Michael X. Martin, William Michals, Tony Roach, Sarah Jane Shanks and William Youmans.

“Bright Star’s” creative team includes choreography by Josh Rhodes, scenic design by Eugene Lee, costume design by Jane Greenwood, lighting design by Japhy Weideman, sound design by Nevin Steinberg, hair and wig design by Tom Watson, musical supervision by Peter Asher, musical direction and vocal arrangements by Rob Berman, orchestrations by August Eriksmoen, and casting by Howie Cherpakov. Production photos by Nick Stokes.

“Bright Star” runs at the Cort Theatre (138 West 48th Street) on the following schedule: on the following schedule: Tuesday and Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday at 8:00 p.m.; matinees Wednesday and Saturday at 2:00 p.m.; and matinee on Sunday at 3:00 p.m. Tickets at $45.00 - $149.00 can be purchased by visiting or by calling 800-447-7400. For groups of 10 or more, call 1-800-BROADWAY, ext. 2. For more info, visit Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes including one intermission.
0 Comments | Add Comment | Permalink | Posted by David Roberts on Tuesday, April 5, 2016

<< 301-350 Posts 351 - 400 of 1053 401-450 >>